Humans Caused Australia's Ice Age Extinctions, Tooth Study Says
Sean Markey
for National Geographic News
January 24, 2007
An underground trove of fossil skeletons found in Australia suggests humans, not climate change, drove the continent's large land animals to extinction 40,000 to 50,000 years ago.
The conclusion is based on the first scientific analysis of a rare cache of fossils exhumed from three caves in the arid Nullarbor Plain of southern Australia.
First discovered in 2002, the three- to four-million-year-old caverns have yielded fossils of 70 animal species dating from 800,000 to 400,000 years ago.
The menagerie includes 10 intact skeletons of Thylacoleo (lionlike marsupials), a nearly hippo-size giant wombat, and 23 kangaroo species—8 of them new to science.
Gavin Prideaux, a paleontologist at the Western Australian Museum who led the study, said the fossils are remarkable for their diversity and near-perfect condition.
The ancient bones also open an unprecedented window to the environment and climate of that part of Australia during the mid-Pleistocene (800,000 to 200,000 years ago), Prideaux said.
The findings reveal important clues to what eventually drove the plain's large Ice Age animals extinct.
Teeth Tell the Tale
The Nullarbor region receives just 8 to 10 inches (20 to 25 centimeters) of rain a year.
"It's incredibly dry and bleak," said study co-author Richard Roberts, a geologist at the University of Wollongong. "Things don't get much worse than that for an animal in search of free water."
But animals do survive there, including hundreds of bird species as well as wombats and kangaroos.
The rich diversity of species found in the ancient caves shows that life was similarly thriving in the region during the Ice Age.
Two new species of tree kangaroos, for example, indicate that 300,000 years ago Nullarbor Plain wasn't as treeless as its name implies.
Researchers also found lizards that favor dry conditions and a high ratio of grazing species.
But the most telling clues, the team says, come from an analysis of tooth enamel from 13 species of ancient kangaroo and a giant wombat.
Isotopes found in tooth enamel can signal the abundance of standing water and certain types of grasses.
Researchers compared their results with a database of similar studies of enamel from modern-day kangaroos and wombats.
The results, reported in tomorrow's issue of the journal Nature, show that Nullarbor was as parched back then as it is now.
Tipping Point
According to John Long, a paleontologist at Museum Victoria and study co-author, the findings "have virtually nailed that climate change wasn't a major factor" in the animals' extinction.
"We were able to establish that this entire assemblage of [Ice Age] megafauna animals was adapted to aridity."
Australia's Ice Age creatures probably employed adaptations like those found in modern kangaroos, the paleontologist said.
Living 'roos can survive on the water from plants alone and time their reproductive cycles to coincide with rainy periods.
Roberts, the Wollongong geologist, said Australia's ancient animals "already were very well adapted to some pretty awful climates, and they didn't get any worse than they did on the Nullarbor Plain."
He notes that a recent study in the journal Geology by many of the same team members suggests that Australia's megafauna were very resilient to climate change.
The scientists therefore believe that hunting pressures and wildfires linked to ancient humans may have finally tipped the balance against Australia's large animals.
As climate shifted, the animals suffered, Roberts said. "But they always bounced back—except about 40,000 to 50,000 years ago, [after which] they never bounced back.
"And the only difference is that people were around on the scene at that stage."
http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news ... ssils.html