A very long article about people who die alone, and about how often little is known about them. It looks at how one such case in Edinburgh was investigated...
'Who were his pals, where did he go?': solving the mysteries of those who die alone
An old man dies in a nursing home, but he isn’t who he seems: can the police piece together the life and death of Mr Lobban?
Mary Paulson-Ellis
Saturday 27 August 2016 11.00 BST
They called him Mr Lobban. That was his name, as far as anyone knew. An elderly gentleman of extreme frailty, who died one late October afternoon in 2012, as the skies darkened and the clocks were about to turn.
The Edinburgh nursing home in which he had lived out his last few years did what they always do when one of their patients is gone. They withdrew from his room and locked the door. Then they called the GP to sign the death certificate and start Mr Lobban on his final journey to the grave.
There was nothing suspicious, nothing untoward. Just a blank on his file in the section marked “next of kin”.
Edinburgh is a small city, a place of roughly half a million people that can feel like a village – scratch beneath the surface and everyone and everything seems connected. Yet there are people every day who die alone or with no apparent family, dead in their bed in a hospital ward or lying face down on their living room floor.
None of us imagines dying without any friends or family nearby. But more and more people live in single-person households. We are living longer, and many of us, inevitably, will outlast every one of those we hold dear.
Public health funerals – those organised and paid for by local authorities – have been on the rise for some years: in November 2015 research by the BBC identified
a growth of 11% across the UK since 2009-10. Scotland saw one of the biggest increases: up 28% in just four years.
Having a public health, or indigent, funeral does not necessarily mean there are no next of kin; it could be that those relatives who have been identified are remote, geographically or otherwise. Or perhaps there simply isn’t enough money to pay for the service. Yet, of the 200 or so public health funerals conducted in Edinburgh each year, there will be at least two or three a month where no next of kin have been traced.
When the GP arrived at the nursing home where Mr Lobban had died, she was confident about the cause: extreme frailty, and peripheral vascular disease. Mr Lobban had been old. That was that. But there was one thing that made her pause before signing off the necessary paperwork – Mr Lobban appeared to have two dates of birth. And several names. Enter Mr St John Shurley. Also, Mr Krebs.
In Scotland, cases of unexplained or unexpected death are the responsibility of the Procurator Fiscal’s office – the Crown. As are establishing identity and cause. In practice, it is the police who step in when an investigation is required.
PC Barry Gordon works in Stirling now, but he is Edinburgh born and bred. He is a methodical man. For several years until 2013 he worked in the Edinburgh inquiry team, a group of officers dedicated to dealing with all non-suspicious and unexplained deaths in the city. It’s a very particular kind of work. As Gordon puts it, “There are some strange deaths where, because of the causes of death or where the person is similar to your age, it’s only natural to impose your own feelings on what that might be like.” As his former colleague, detective constable Steven Donaldson says, “It takes time to get used to death.”
It was PC Gordon who took the call about Mr Lobban. It was he and Donaldson – a reflective, insightful man – who tried to establish who Mr St John Shurley was. And Mr Krebs. And how the three were linked.
etc...
https://www.theguardian.com/global/2016/aug/27/solving-mysteries-those-who-die-alone-mr-lobban
A fascinating and thought provoking story. The links with the other names are eventually found, but much more remains a mystery.
"None of us imagines dying without any friends or family nearby."
But I do, and it seems the most likely way I will die. There are scraps of information here in the flat about my life, and I don't have other alibis that I've lived under, but there's no-one here that knows me at all closely. Most family and friends have somehow drifted away.
This thread is really about me - but you knew that, didn't you.