- Joined
- Aug 18, 2002
- Messages
- 19,407
Man suing over display some found too spooky
November 2, 2004
BY NATASHA KORECKI Staff Reporter
A former Addison firefighter said he put up plywood "tombstones" in his Bloomingdale front yard as Halloween decor. But the names he wrote next to "R.I.P." were carefully chosen in mocking protest of neighbors who pressured him to get rid of the RV parked at his house.
A police officer allegedly handcuffed and arrested the man, Jeffrey Purtell, when he refused to cover the names with duct tape, violating his First Amendment rights, Purtell claims.
Suit filed day after Halloween
The exchange happened two years ago, but Purtell filed the federal lawsuit Monday -- the day after Halloween.
Purtell, who owned the RV, said at the time of the incident that his neighbors were petitioning the village to prohibit RVs from private driveways. Purtell put the fake tombstones in front of the RV and wrote on them names similar to first names of neighbors who were heading the drive for the new ordinance.
On one he wrote: "Here Lies Jimmy, the Olde Towne Idiot. Mean as sin even without his gin. No longer does he wear that stupid old grin. ... Oh no, not where they've sent him!"
People complained, so he covered up the names with duct tape.
But the tape fell off one of the names. That's when a police officer stopped by his house and allegedly ordered him to reapply the tape.
Purtell said when he refused, he was put in handcuffs and arrested. Purtell quickly changed his mind, agreed to take down the tombstones and was let go. But not before the officer caused him to suffer mental anguish, stress and feelings of helplessness, all alleged violations for which he's suing on top of the First Amendment violations.
A Bloomingdale police spokesperson was not familiar with the lawsuit and other police officials could not be reached for comment.
http://www.suntimes.com/output/news/cst-nws-hallo02.html