• We have updated the guidelines regarding posting political content: please see the stickied thread on Website Issues.

Sunken Sicilian Monolith May Be More Than 9,000 Years Old

EnolaGaia

I knew the job was dangerous when I took it ...
(ACCOUNT RETIRED)
Joined
Jul 19, 2004
Messages
29,622
Location
Out of Bounds
News story summary ...

In deep water off the coast of Sicily, scientists have found a large and very mysterious monolith that is believed to have been hewn from rock some 10,000 years ago. ...

The stone artifact--which is pierced by three holes--is about 12 meters long and roughly square in cross section, with each side measuring about 2 meters. It was discovered by a diver on Sept. 16, 2014 at a depth of about 40 meters on what was once an island in the Sicilian Channel ...

Exactly who made the monolith? No one knows for sure, though evidence suggests that it was fashioned by members of an ancient Mediterranean culture who lived in the area until their land was swallowed by rising sea levels some 9,ooo years ago. ...

As for the monolith's purpose, it might have been "some sort of a lighthouse or an anchoring system," according to Lodolo.

The paper written about this discovery can be accessed at:

http://www.researchgate.net/publica...n_Sea)_Evidence_for_Mesolithic_human_activity
 
Here's another online news item about the monolith discovery ...
Mysterious 10,000-Year-Old ‘Atlantis’ Monolith Is Found In Sea Off Sicily
7 August 2015

A mysterious Stonehenge-style monolith has been discovered in deep sea off the coast of Sicily - offering an insight into ancient civilisations lost beneath the waves.

The monolith, found by researchers from Tel Aviv University, has three holes of similar diameter along its length.

The researchers believe it was man-made around 10,000 years ago.

‘There are no reasonable known natural processes that may produce these elements,’ wrote Zvi Ben-Avraham of Tel Aviv University.

The monolith was found in 131 feet of water at Pantelleria Vecchia Bank - an area believed to have been colonised by an ancient civilisation which was submerged 9,500 years ago.

Some interpretations of Plato’s stories of ‘Atlantis’ identify the legendary ‘lost’ island with Sicily.

The researchers write, ‘The Sicilian Channel is one of the shallow shelves of the central Mediterranean region where the consequences of changing sea-level were most dramatic and intense.

‘This discovery reveals the technological innovation and development achieved by the Mesolithic inhabitants in the Sicilian Channel region.

‘Such an effort undoubtedly reveals important technical skills and great engineering. It could have been some sort of a lighthouse or an anchoring system, for example.’
SOURCE: https://uk.news.yahoo.com/mysterious-10-000-year-old--atlantis--monolith-is-found-in-sea-off-sicily-105851857.html
 
Last edited:
Here's more detailed account from the Discovery website ...

Underwater 'Stonehenge' Monolith Found Off Coast of Sicily
AUG 6, 2015 04:50 PM ET // BY ROSSELLA LORENZI

Archaeologists have discovered a mysterious Stonehenge-style monolith in the deep sea off the coast of Sicily, shedding new light on the earliest civilizations in the Mediterranean basin.

Broken in two parts, the 3.2-foot-long monolith has a rather regular shape and features three holes of similar diameter. One, which can be found at its end, crosses it completely from part to part, the others appear at two sides of the massive stone.

Such features leave no doubt that the monolith was man-made some 10,000 years ago.

“There are no reasonable known natural processes that may produce these elements,” Zvi Ben-Avraham, from the Department of Earth Sciences at Tel Aviv University, and Emanuele Lodolo, from the National Institute of Oceanography and Experimental Geophysics in Trieste, Italy, wrote in the Journal of Archaeological Science. ...

The monolith was found at a depth of 131 feet, on what was once an island in the Sicilian Channel. Called Pantelleria Vecchia Bank, the island was located some 24 miles north of the volcanic island of Pantelleria and was submerged during a massive flood about 9,500 years ago.

Indeed, the entire geography of the Mediterranean Basin was radically altered by the increase in sea level following the Last Glacial Maximum.

“The Sicilian Channel is one of the shallow shelves of the central Mediterranean region where the consequences of changing sea-level were most dramatic and intense,” the researchers wrote. ...

During the Last Glacial Maximum, the Adventure Plateau — the shallowest, north-western sector of the Sicilian Channel — was connected to Sicily, forming a broad peninsula that was separated from the North African coastline by about 30 miles.

“The gradual increase of the sea level caused the flooding of most of the peninsula, with the exception of some morphological highs that, until at least the Early Holocene, formed an archipelago of several islands separated by stretches of extremely shallow sea,” the researchers said.

One of those islands was the Pantelleria Vecchia Bank, where the massive monolith was found and where an ancient civilization thrived. These ancient people possibly colonized and settled the various islands of the archipelago, attracted by a suitable climate and a geographical position between Europe and Africa.

Everything ended about 9,500 years ago, when, according to the post-glacial curve of sea-level change for the Italian coasts, seawater submerged Pantelleria Vecchia Bank. ...

“This discovery reveals the technological innovation and development achieved by the Mesolithic inhabitants in the Sicilian Channel region,” Lodolo told Discovery News.

He noted that the monolith, which weights about 15 tons, was made of a single, large block that required cutting, extraction, transportation and installation.

“Such an effort undoubtedly reveals important technical skills and great engineering,” Lodolo said.

It is not known what the monolith’s fuction was or whether it was part of a large complex.

“Most likely the structure was functional to the settlement. These people were used to fishing and trading with the neighboring islands,” Lodolo said.

“It could have been some sort of a lighthouse or an anchoring system, for example,” he added. ...

The most famous archaeological discovery of Mesolithic age is the monumental temple complex of Göbekli Tepe, in south-eastern Turkey. Excavated by a German team in the 1960s, the site has been dated to about 11,600 years ago and is believed to have been a religious center or sanctuary serving a well-organized settlement.

“Almost everything that we do know about prehistoric cultures derives from settlements that are now on land. On the contrary, an extensive archaeological record of early settlings lies on the sea-floor of our continental shelves,” Lodolo said.

“If we want to trace the origins of civilization in the Mediterranean region, we must focus on the now-submerged shelf areas,” he added.
SOURCE: news.discovery.com/history/archaeology/underwater-stonehenge-monolith-found-off-coast-of-sicily-150806.htm
Link is dead. The MIA news article can be accessed via the Wayback Machine:

https://web.archive.org/web/2015080...monolith-found-off-coast-of-sicily-150806.htm
 
Last edited:
The DailyGrail has a story from an archaeological journal about a monolith found in shallow waters off Sicily which is at least 9,000 years old.


monolith-photo.jpg


"Researchers believe the site was abandoned as it was inundated by the rising sea at the end of the last Ice Age, almost 10,000 years ago (although they seem careful not to suggest when the monolith may have been created…though one of their samples appears to date to around 40,000 BP)."

Blimey!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The DailyGrail has a story from an archaeological journal about a monolith found in shallow waters off Sicily which is at least 9,000 years old.

monolith-photo.jpg


"Researchers believe the site was abandoned as it was inundated by the rising sea at the end of the last Ice Age, almost 10,000 years ago (although they seem careful not to suggest when the monolith may have been created…though one of their samples appears to date to around 40,000 BP)."

Blimey!
It must be quite hard to date this rock, seeing as most rocks are millions of years old, I believe they usually date prehistoric sites like this by things found next to or beneath monoliths, which, given this location would be a lot more difficult.
 
Here are the bibliographic details and abstract for the 2015 article.


Emanuele Lodolo, Zvi Ben-Avraham,
A submerged monolith in the Sicilian Channel (central Mediterranean Sea): Evidence for Mesolithic human activity,
Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports,
Volume 3, 2015, Pages 398-407. ISSN 2352-409X.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jasrep.2015.07.003.
(https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352409X15300535)

Abstract
The ancient geography of the Mediterranean Basin was profoundly changed by the increase in sea level following the Last Glacial Maximum. This global event has led to the retreat of the coastlines, especially in lowland areas and shallow shelves, such as the Sicilian Channel. The NW sector of this shelf, known as Adventure Plateau, is studded by isolated shoals mostly composed of Late Miocene carbonate rocks and by some volcanic edifices. These shoals, until at least the Early Holocene, formed an archipelago of several islands separated by stretches of extremely shallow sea. One of these submerged features – the Pantelleria Vecchia Bank – located 60km south of Sicily, has been extensively surveyed using geophysical and geological methods. It is composed of two main shoals, connected seaward by a rectilinear ridge which encloses an embayment. Here we present morphological evidence, underwater observations, and results of petrographic analysis of a man-made, 12m long monolith resting on the sea-floor of the embayment at a water depth of 40m. It is broken into two parts, and has three regular holes: one at its end which passes through from part to part, the others in two of its sides. The monolith is composed of calcirudites of Late Pleistocene age, as determined from radiocarbon measurements conducted on several shell fragments extracted from the rock samples. The same age and composition characterize the metre-size blocks forming the rectilinear ridge. The rest of the rocks composing the shoals are mostly Tortonian limestones–sandstones, as revealed by their fossil content. Extrapolating ages from the local sea level curve, we infer that seawater inundated the inner lands at 9350±200yearB.P., the upper limit which can be reasonably taken for the site abandonment. This discovery provides evidence for a significant Mesolithic human activity in the Sicilian Channel region.

SOURCE: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2352409X15300535
 
Here are the bibliographic details and abstract for the 2015 article.


Emanuele Lodolo, Zvi Ben-Avraham,
A submerged monolith in the Sicilian Channel (central Mediterranean Sea): Evidence for Mesolithic human activity,
Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports,
Volume 3, 2015, Pages 398-407. ISSN 2352-409X.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jasrep.2015.07.003.
(https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352409X15300535)

Abstract
The ancient geography of the Mediterranean Basin was profoundly changed by the increase in sea level following the Last Glacial Maximum. This global event has led to the retreat of the coastlines, especially in lowland areas and shallow shelves, such as the Sicilian Channel. The NW sector of this shelf, known as Adventure Plateau, is studded by isolated shoals mostly composed of Late Miocene carbonate rocks and by some volcanic edifices. These shoals, until at least the Early Holocene, formed an archipelago of several islands separated by stretches of extremely shallow sea. One of these submerged features – the Pantelleria Vecchia Bank – located 60km south of Sicily, has been extensively surveyed using geophysical and geological methods. It is composed of two main shoals, connected seaward by a rectilinear ridge which encloses an embayment. Here we present morphological evidence, underwater observations, and results of petrographic analysis of a man-made, 12m long monolith resting on the sea-floor of the embayment at a water depth of 40m. It is broken into two parts, and has three regular holes: one at its end which passes through from part to part, the others in two of its sides. The monolith is composed of calcirudites of Late Pleistocene age, as determined from radiocarbon measurements conducted on several shell fragments extracted from the rock samples. The same age and composition characterize the metre-size blocks forming the rectilinear ridge. The rest of the rocks composing the shoals are mostly Tortonian limestones–sandstones, as revealed by their fossil content. Extrapolating ages from the local sea level curve, we infer that seawater inundated the inner lands at 9350±200yearB.P., the upper limit which can be reasonably taken for the site abandonment. This discovery provides evidence for a significant Mesolithic human activity in the Sicilian Channel region.

SOURCE: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2352409X15300535
"Just being very curious," I'm trying to imagine what the holes were cut in the rock/monolith for?
Maybe, it contained a tall wooden center pole so it could be seen from a greater distance, and the two side poles could have held a further two wooden signposts one on each of the two faces and held within the stone to show a safer route to tread?:thought:
*Something like this maybe?
Sign Post.png
 
Last edited:
I agree ... The holes suggest something was inserted into them. However, there are problems in reaching any conclusions on what the possibilities may be.

I'm unable to locate the one sort of illustration that would be most helpful - a sketch or diagram of the monolith / megalith illustrating its overall shape and locations of the known holes. In particular, I'd love to see an end view illustrating the angular orientations of the holes around the (more or less) longitudinal axis of the stone.

Another bit I've not yet seen is any commentary on whether and how the stone might have been erected vertically - e.g., how much of it may have been buried.
 
I agree ... The holes suggest something was inserted into them. However, there are problems in reaching any conclusions on what the possibilities may be.

I'm unable to locate the one sort of illustration that would be most helpful - a sketch or diagram of the monolith / megalith illustrating its overall shape and locations of the known holes. In particular, I'd love to see an end view illustrating the angular orientations of the holes around the (more or less) longitudinal axis of the stone.

Another bit I've not yet seen is any commentary on whether and how the stone might have been erected vertically - e.g., how much of it may have been buried.
This webpage holds better info. . .
https://daneshyari.com/article/preview/7446556.pdf
 

Unfortunately, it only contains text from the opening pages of the report. Here is the specific description it provides of the monolith's form and configuration ...
... At ~15 m from the base of the southern semi- circular ridge, an important morphological element, easily recognizable from the bathymetric maps (Fig. 3), is an elongated monolith laying on the sea-floor, isolated from the rest of the outcrops, and broken in half, as appears from inspections carried out by divers (Fig. 4). The good match between the two adjacent parts suggests that it was originally a single block. Its length is 12 m, with a recognizable squared section of about 2 m, particularly regular in its southern half. The longitudinal axis of the monolith is oriented N50°E. A rounded hole with a diameter of about 60 cm passes right through the monolith, at 50 cm from one end. Another hole of the same diameter, but not crossing the whole monolith, is present in one of its sides. It is about 40 cm deep and is located midway in the monolith, at a right angle with respect to the first hole. Another hole, but less regular, with a diameter of about 50 cm, is found along the other side of the monolith. Also this hole is located midway in the monolith.
https://daneshyari.com/article/preview/7446556.pdf
 
The full 2015 research article can be accessed at:

https://montezaga.files.wordpress.com/2015/08/pantelleria-monolite-2015.pdf

Here is the relevant text from the Interpretation section ...
4. Interpretation

From the data we have here presented and analysed, it can be inferred that the monolith discovered in the PVB is not a natural feature, but man-made. The elements that combine to formulate this interpretation can be listed as follows:

• the monolith has a rather regular shape;

• the monolith has three regular holes of similar diameter: one that
crosses it completely on its top, and another two at two sides of the monolith; there are no reasonable known natural processes that may produce these elements;

• the monolith is made from stone other than those which constitute all the neighbouring outcrops, and is quite isolated with respect to them; and

• the lithology and age of the rock that makes up the monolith are similar to those that make up the blocks of the rectilinear ridge closing the embayment.

The presence of the monolith suggests extensive human activity in the PVB. It was cut and extracted as a single stone from the outer rectilinear ridge situated about 300 m to the south, and then transported and possibly erected. From the size of the monolith, we may presume that it weights about 15 t. The information so far available does not allow us however to formulate hypotheses about the specific function of this monolith. It is however reasonable to assume that the PVB represented an important line of communication with the interior, because located midway between Sicily and Tunisia.
(pp. 403 - 404)
 
Here are the relevant bits from the research article's Discussion section ...
5. Discussion

The obtained age for the PVB site places it within the beginning of the Mesolithic. Perhaps the most important archaeological discovery of the Mesolithic age is the monumental temple complex of Göbekli Tepe ... Carbon-dated to about 11,600 year B.P., this site is believed to have been a religious centre or sanctuary (Mann, 2011) serving a well-organized settlement (or series of settlements) ... Up until its excavation in the 1990s (Schmidt, 2000), archaeologists believed that only properly settled farming communities were capable of building a monumental complex like Göbekli Tepe. ... Before the discovery of this monumental complex, the two Neolithic stone temples of Ġgantija in Gozo (Maltese Islands), unmatched by any other architectural construction in the Mediterranean region, represented the oldest man-made religious structures in the world (Trump, 2002). Regarding the underwater sites known to date, the PVB site is older than the Neolithic Atlit Yam site off the north coast of Israel, dated between 6900 and 6300 B.C. (Galili and Nir, 1993) and now lying between 8 and 12 m beneath the sea surface, and the city of Pavlopetri, situated 3 ÷ 4 m underwater off the coast of southern Peloponnese (Greece), until now considered the world oldest (about 5000 years old) submerged archaeological town. ...

The discovery of the submerged site in the Sicilian Channel may significantly expand our knowledge of the earliest civilizations in the Mediterranean basin and our views on technological innovation and development achieved by the Mesolithic inhabitants. The monolith found, made of a single, large block, required a cutting, extraction, transportation and installation, which undoubtedly reveals important technical skills and great engineering. The belief that our ancestors lacked the knowledge, skill and technology to exploit marine resources or make sea crossings, must be progressively abandoned. The recent findings of submerged archaeology have definitively removed the idea of “technological primitivism” often attributed to hunter-gatherers coastal settlers.
(p. 405)
 
Back
Top