- Joined
- Aug 18, 2002
- Messages
- 19,407
Jodi trial shown 'Satanic' jotter
The jury in the Jodi Jones murder trial has been shown her boyfriend's school jotter, which was covered in Satanic slogans.
Luke Mitchell, who is now 16, and denies killing the Midlothian teenager, handed in an essay with references to the Devil, a court heard.
His former teacher told the High Court in Edinburgh she was concerned about an essay entitled Pain and Suffering.
It questioned God's existence and said the world needed Satanic people.
The teenager, who was 14 at the time Jodi died, has lodged two special defences, one of alibi and one of incrimination.
Geraldine Mackie, 41, taught Mr Mitchell in his third year at St David's Roman Catholic High School in Dalkeith.
She expressed concern about his English essay which said: "People like you need Satanic people like me to keep the balance."
Mrs Mackie showed the court Mr Mitchell's English jotter which had the numbers 666 and references to the devil on the front cover.
This is an assortment of rubbish on a kid's jotter, isn't it?
Donald Findlay
Defence counsel
The word Satan was written across the back of the jotter with the phrase: "I have tasted the devil's green blood."
She told prosecuting advocate Alan Turnbull QC that she referred the teenager to a guidance teacher after he wrote the essay, the first time she had taken the step with a pupil in 15 years as a teacher.
In another essay, Mr Mitchell wrote: "So what if I am a Goth in a Catholic school? So what if I dress in baggy clothes?
"Just because I am more violent than others and cut myself, does that justify some pompous git of a teacher to refer me to a psychiatrist?
"Just because I have chosen to follow the teachings of Satan doesn't mean I need psychiatric help."
Defence advocate, Donald Findlay, QC, suggested that Mr Mitchell was just another rebellious pupil.
Mrs Mackie said: "Well, from my point of view I was quite concerned about him and the nature of his rebellion."
A passage in an essay read: "How can anyone be good because without evil there can be no good, so it must be good to be evil."
Four-letter insults
Mr Findlay said: "It seems to be pretty thoughtful for his tender years."
The QC showed the court words scrawled on the back of Mr Mitchell's school jotters which included four-letter insults levelled at the Queen and the world and another profane demand that people "stay out of my mind".
Mr Findlay asked: "This is an assortment of rubbish on a kid's jotter, isn't it?"
Mrs Mackie replied: "Yes."
The court also heard extracts from Jodi Jones' diary where she'd written she thought she was in love with Luke Mitchell.
Michelle Tierney, 17, a former classmate of Mr Mitchell's, told the court he said he had imagined himself getting "stoned" and killing someone.
She said Mr Mitchell said it would be funny, before he stubbed a cigarette out on his hand.
Mr Mitchell denies murdering his 14-year-old girlfriend Jodi last June.
The trial before Lord Nimmo Smith continues.
---------------------
Story from BBC NEWS:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/2/hi/u ... 042321.stm
Published: 2004/11/25 17:56:20 GMT
© BBC MMIV
JODI JONES MURDER TRIAL: YOU NEED SATANIC PEOPLE LIKE ME TO HELP BALANCE
Nov 26 2004
Accused's essay worried his teacher
By Gordon Mcilwraith
MURDER accused Luke Mitchell wrote a disturbing school essay praising Satan, it was revealed yesterday.
It was supposed to be a short story about the end of the world for his English class.
But the teenager referred to shaking hands with the Devil and described Lucifer as a fallen angel.
He also wrote: 'People like you need Satanic people like me to keep the balance.'
His teacher was so worried about the essay - written six months before Jodi Jones was killed - that she suggested Mitchell should get help.
And in another essay he said: 'Whose business is it anyway if I cut myself just because I am more violent than others.'
In several jotters he scribbled his favourite quote from the late Nirvana rock star Kurt Cobain: 'The finest day I ever had was when tomorrow never came.'
The High Court in Edinburgh also heard that Mitchell, now 16, told a girl he could imagine himself getting stoned and killing someone and how funny it would be.
But Donald Findlay, QC, defending, suggested some of Mitchell's words contained sound ideas and were thought-provoking.
He believed they might have been merely the writings of a rebellious teenager.
Geraldine Mackie, 41, who teaches English at St David's High School in Dalkeith, said Mitchell was a third year pupil in her class.
She described him as being 'quite rebellious' and became concerned when he handed in an essay in January last year.
She continued: 'Some of the tone I found worrying. It was the first time I had ever referred on a piece of writing to the guidance staff.
'Quite a few things in it I found a little bit disturbing.'
Advocate depute Alan Turnbull, QC, prosecuting, then read part of the essay which said: 'If God forgives everyone then why the need to be sent to Hell?
'If you ask me, God's just a futile excuse at most for a bunch of fools to go around annoying others who want nothing to do with them.
'Are these people insane? Open your eyes.
'People like you need Satanic people like me to help the balance.
'Once you shake hands with the Devil you then have truly experienced life. Lucifer is a fallen angel.'
Mrs Mackie agreed he had has also written several other things on the cover of jotters including '666', 'SATAN' and 'Master Lead Us Into Hell.'
Mr Turnbull then produced another of Mitchell's jotters which had written on it: 'I offer my flesh, blood and soul to the dark god of Hell.' On yet another he wrote: 'I have tasted the Devil's green blood.'
Mrs Mackie said on a separate occasion she had asked the class to write an essay discussing whether geriatrics should be allowed to die.
This time, part of Mitchell's work said: 'So what if I am a Goth at a Catholic school.
'So what if I dress in baggy clothes and like different music. Whose business is it other than my own if I cut myself? Just because I am more violent than others does that justify some pompous git of a teacher referring me to a psychologist.
'Just because I have chosen to follow the teachings of Satan doesn't mean I need psychiatric help.
'Just because my favourite saying is 'the finest day I ever had was when tomorrow never came' doesn't qualify me as having a troubled life.'
Cross-examined by Mr Findlay, she agreed that some of Mitchell's essay on the end of the world was quite thought-provoking, especially for a 14-year-old boy.
Mr Findlay said: 'We seem to have a young man who, on a view of it, raises challenging views and original questions about the worth of a belief in God.'
She also accepted his description of what was written on Mitchell's jotters as an 'assortment of rubbish.'
Earlier, 17-year-old Michelle Tierney recalled a remark Mitchell made when she and a friend met in a park early last year. She said: 'He said he could imagine himself going out and getting stoned and killing someone and how funny it would be.
'I didn't think it was funny at all. He didn't go into any detail or anything.'
Mitchell, who was smoking a cigarette, then stubbed it out on the back of his hand.
Fellow pupil Richard Travers, 16, who was in Mitchell's form class, remembered once seeing him playing with a knife.
Mitchell made a hand movement across his neck and remarked that was the way to slit a person's throat.
Mitchell denies murdering 14-year-old Jodi on June 30 last year at an area near Roan's Dyke path in Dalkeith, Midlothian, by slashing her with a knife.
He has lodged defences of alibi and incrimination to the murder allegation.
Mitchell has also pleaded not guilty to carrying a knife or knives and supplying cannabis.
Jodi's mum, Judith, is expected to give evidence today.
Source