PeniG
Justified & Ancient
- Joined
- Dec 31, 2003
- Messages
- 2,434
We just got back. I have not read the comic and am not the primary audience, but my husband did read the comic (pulled it out and re-read it for the occasion) and was cheesed off that the release date was pushed back from November 5. As soon as the lights came up afterward, he started telling me differences from the book, but it's telling that some the of differences were things that, in themselves, he quite liked. The behavior of the public at the climax was very satisfying, and Stephen Frye's character, was, well, Stephen Frye in the closet and too naive for his circumstances, and we both liked him.
The criticism that a British comic was turned into an American movie is well-taken. From this side of the pond the politics don't look anything like as muddled as they apparently do over there, especially once you let go of any grounding in real political systems or philosophies. This is all happening in myth-space, and if you don't have that down by the time all those dead people appear in the final crowd sequence you'll have had a really bad time at this movie. I'm afraid I kept getting sidetracked by practical considerations, myself. (Where does he grow those roses and how does he get them to bloom to that stage when he needs them?)
It's a far from perfect movie, but with the right mindset you can have a good time. In any case, if you liked the comic, you'll want to go so you can lecture your friends on What Went Wrong. C'mon, you know that gives you plenty enough pleasure to cover a matinee ticket!
The criticism that a British comic was turned into an American movie is well-taken. From this side of the pond the politics don't look anything like as muddled as they apparently do over there, especially once you let go of any grounding in real political systems or philosophies. This is all happening in myth-space, and if you don't have that down by the time all those dead people appear in the final crowd sequence you'll have had a really bad time at this movie. I'm afraid I kept getting sidetracked by practical considerations, myself. (Where does he grow those roses and how does he get them to bloom to that stage when he needs them?)
It's a far from perfect movie, but with the right mindset you can have a good time. In any case, if you liked the comic, you'll want to go so you can lecture your friends on What Went Wrong. C'mon, you know that gives you plenty enough pleasure to cover a matinee ticket!