Sheriff's office seizes 87 horses, citing starvation, neglect
Chereen Langrill
The Idaho Statesman | Edition Date: 01-27-2005
At least 87 horses, many described as starving and severely neglected, were impounded from a Gem County ranch Wednesday.
Idaho Humane Society and sheriff's officials describe the animals' condition as shocking and "pitiful," but the rancher says most of the horses are healthy and he vows to get them back.
The humane society impounded the horses from a ranch in Sweet Wednesday morning, and authorities spent most of the day at the scene, gathering information.
Paul and Karen Shay are each charged with 10 misdemeanor counts of animal neglect according to Gem County Sheriff Clint Short.
Paul Shay said his wife is "crushed" that the horses were taken away. She had raised some of the horses from birth and has had them more than a dozen years, he said.
It wasn't necessary to take all the animals away because most were healthy, Shay said.
"When you've got 90 head of horses you're going to have a few thin horses," he said, adding that the couple's horses were well fed.
Shay said he believes the horses were seized not because of their condition but because of plans — part of Gov. Dirk Kempthorne's recently announced proposals for Idaho highways — to extend Idaho 16 through Gem County to Valley County.
"The truth is they're putting a four-lane highway through Sweet," Shay said. "The highway is going to go right through my place."
The Shays have lived on the more than 76 acres that border part of Butte Road since 1990.
Shay said he believes the county has been planning to seize the horses in order to pressure the couple into selling their property for the highway.
He said he plans to hire an attorney and will fight to get the horses back.
"Absolutely. That's my wife's life," Shay said. "That's what she lives for."
Short said the sheriff's office received a call Monday from someone who said they were concerned the Shays' horses weren't being fed.
A deputy went to the property to look at the horses, and authorities returned Tuesday with the state veterinarian, who determined the animals were in poor health, Short said.
"It's just pitiful," Short said. "I have animals myself, and I just can't believe it."
Idaho Humane Society spokeswoman Dee Fugit said the horses had no access to vegetation and were standing in mud up to their knees, eating their own feces to survive.
"They had nothing," Fugit said. "Nothing."
Shay denied the horses had no access to food and said a 24-hour caretaker was on the property to ensure the animals were fed and cared for when the couple was away from the ranch.
Fugit said one of the foals was trying to nurse off a horse that wasn't his mother because his mother wasn't producing milk. Another foal had trouble eating today because it didn't know how to eat, she said.
Many of the horses suffered from eye problems, had manes and tails covered with burrs and had severely overgrown hooves, she said.
One of the horses is pregnant and has problems with her back legs.
The horses that need medical treatment will stay on the new Idaho Humane Society Rescue Ranch in south Boise.
The other horses will stay at a ranch in Gem County, where they will begin a monitored feeding regimen to regain their health, Fugit said.
The Shays will be formally charged in a Gem County courtroom on Tuesday, Short said. It will be up to a judge to determine whether to return the horses to the couple, Fugit said.
"There's no reason to take all those animals," Shay said.
"They came and wiped us out. More than 14 years work and they took it all."
Additional Information
How to help
The Idaho Humane Society is a non-profit organization and doesn't have a budget set aside for animal rescues. Money will be used for rehabilitation efforts, nutritional supplements, halters and other equine supplies. To make arrangements to donate equine supplies, contact Kim Neill at 331-8553. Monetary donations can be made by contacting Chris Moore at 387-2760 or directly to the Idaho Humane Society donation account at any U.S. Bank branch in the Boise area.
Donations of alfalfa or grass hay are needed by the Gem County Sheriff's Office. The agency will take some of the rescued horses and care for them in a property in Gem County.
To help, Sheriff Clint Short suggests calling the Gem County Dispatchers at 365-3521, or drop off the hay at the Emmett fairgrounds on South Johns near the base of Freezeout Hill.
Previous case
In April 2004, the Idaho Humane Society rescued 56 malnourished horses from a Meridian pasture.
Most of the animals rescued Wednesday from Gem County didn't appear to be as thin as the Meridian horses, Fugit said, but living conditions were worse than those in the Meridian case.
The Gem County horses had no visible source of food. The Meridian horses had been eating a neighbor's rose bushes.
The owner of the Meridian horses signed them over to the humane society and was not prosecuted, and the horses were adopted.