• We have updated the guidelines regarding posting political content: please see the stickied thread on Website Issues.

Physical Mediumship

I chanced across a Podcasts (Anomaly) with Dr Ian Rubensteing, who is a practicing GP in North London and also a medium. I was interested enough to look a bit deeper and realised I had come across him before in another Podcast (Unexplained) some years ago.

It seems unusual for a GP to openly admit he is also a practicing medium, and he has also published a book, Consulting Spirit, A Doctor’s Experience with Practical Mediumship, from which the following quote comes.

“One morning during a busy clinic my dead grandfather dropped in for a chat...
This sent me off on a journey: a mad dash through territory populated by mediums, psychics, poltergeists, and ghost hunters. Along the way I met some fascinating and often strange people.”

https://www.amazon.co.uk/CONSULTING...1652&sprefix=dr+ian+rubenstein,aps,111&sr=8-1

Anyway, if anyone is interested in his unusual story here are a couple of links to the podcasts.

https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/anomaly-paranormal-podcast/id1525156635

https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/the-unexplained-with-howard-hughes/id155963493?i=1000428495804
 
Tempest63 said:
It seems unusual for a GP to openly admit he is also a practicing medium, and he has also published a book, Consulting Spirit, A Doctor’s Experience with Practical Mediumship, from which the following quote comes.
Click to expand...
The Kindle edition is £6.66. :omg:
:chuckle:
 
Yes I remember him explaining that as I had been getting a bit bemused by the Americanisms. Just looked up my orders. I got it in April '16 and was confident I'd got it for 99p well bu88er me must have been having a funny turn, I NEVER buy kindle books at the full price but in this case I did. :evillaugh: I enjoyed the read wasn't totally convinced or totally disbelieving either.
 
Sollywos said:
wasn't totally convinced or totally disbelieving either.
Click to expand...
Here's my take on it: with non-fiction there are three levels of honesty.

1. Factual and externally checkable.
2. Possibly bollocks but believed by the writer.
3. A pack of entertaining lies.

Books on spirituality can only fall into the second or third categories.
Authors might chuck in aspects of (1) to sound more truthful.
There definitely were a 9/11 disaster and an Indian Ocean tsunami, for example, but we only have our author's word that they foresaw them or spoke with deceased victims.

I've enjoyed books by the likes of Doris Stokes, Colin Fry and Derek Acorah, all colossal liars and fakes who were continually debunked. Great yarns though. :chuckle:
 
escargot said:
I've enjoyed books by the likes of Doris Stokes, Colin Fry and Derek Acorah, all colossal liars and fakes who were continually debunked. Great yarns though.
Click to expand...

yup! Load of old bobbins is my reaction to many fortean instances - including Enfield, Amityville, all phenomena = demonic, pagan survival into modern times etc etc etc.

Doesn't stop me reading about them avidly and finding debate on them stimulating and worthwhile. It's the whining ooooooooooh someone disagrees with me so I'm going to throw my toys out the pram reaction that isn't fortean ( unless as a subject in itself) and not honest belief or disbelief.
 
Frideswide said:
yup! Load of old bobbins is my reaction to many fortean instances - including Enfield, Amityville, all phenomena = demonic, pagan survival into modern times etc etc etc.

Doesn't stop me reading about them avidly and finding debate on them stimulating and worthwhile. It's the whining ooooooooooh someone disagrees with me so I'm going to throw my toys out the pram reaction that isn't fortean ( unless as a subject in itself) and not honest belief or disbelief.
Click to expand...
Heh yup. Enfield and Amityville're prime examples of good old-fashioned tosh.
There are many more.

We Brits don't go much for demons either. :chuckle:
 
Frideswide said:
yup! Load of old bobbins is my reaction to many fortean instances - including Enfield, Amityville, all phenomena = demonic, pagan survival into modern times etc etc etc.

Doesn't stop me reading about them avidly and finding debate on them stimulating and worthwhile. It's the whining ooooooooooh someone disagrees with me so I'm going to throw my toys out the pram reaction that isn't fortean ( unless as a subject in itself) and not honest belief or disbelief.
Click to expand...
Forteans are the least gullible people, we've seen it all before popular books by the well known TV mediums are not really meant for the likes of us, we demand more evidence than they can ever supply but also a little humility from the author, which seems to be in short supply in the genre

I have no doubt there are some very genuine and good mediums out there, but they are rare, of course there are those that are delusional and think they are!

To me good evidence is

  1. Witnessed by others (preferably unconnected or without skin in the game)
  2. Good Evidence of existence (Names, dates, addresses knowledge unknown to many)
 
Robbrent said:
Forteans are the least gullible people, we've seen it all before popular books by the well known TV mediums are not really meant for the likes of us, we demand more evidence than they can ever supply but also a little humility from the author, which seems to be in short supply in the genre
Click to expand...
I was brought up with ghost books (also those on the subjects of UFOs, Bigfoot, Yetis, the Hollow Earth, ESP etc) courtesy of my Forteanly-minded father. Ghosts are my very favourite subject to read about.

If I want to read popular books by the well known TV mediums then I certainly will. :chuckle:
 
escargot said:
I was brought up with ghost books (also those on the subjects of UFOs, Bigfoot, Yetis, the Hollow Earth, ESP etc) courtesy of my Forteanly-minded father. Ghosts are my very favourite subject to read about.

If I want to read popular books by the well known TV mediums then I certainly will. :chuckle:
Click to expand...
I don't think there is problem nor a prohibition in reading them, but as for believing them or treating them as entertaining works of fiction, I don't really read much fiction but I am aware that death and the hereafter sells nearly as well as sex, I prefer witness accounts and research that covers all bases, but putting my faith (as to the reality or otherwise of the hereafter) into the hands of a TV medium just doesn't cut the mustard, the whole panoply of Fortean phenomena interests me, just the whole weirdness of the world and the crazy humans that live here (I'm talking to you lot, not me obviously;) )
 
escargot said:
Having recently mentioned Doris Stokes, Colin Fry and Derek Acorah, all now deceased, I'm wondering when we'll hear from them again. :thought:
Click to expand...
They are probably forbidden from contacting this mortal plain as punishment for all their depict, or if the cosmic joker is feeling humorous (when is he or she not humorous ) they may have been reincarnated without a glimpse of the hereafter
 
frankiefelix said:
Quite a few references to Harry Price here but not a "Rosalie" thread SFAIAA. I may have to find a YouTube feature and link it.
Click to expand...
If you haven't already listened to it, the Dark Histories episode devoted to Harry Price and Rosalie may be of interest:

https://www.darkhistories.com/harry-price-the-seance-of-rosalie/

That was the one case that left arch-sceptic and debunker Price undecided as, whilst suspecting a possible hoax, he couldn't see how the "materialisation" of a young girl could have been faked.
If you'd like to know the postscript to the case, then click below...

A letter sent some years after Price's death was a confession from the woman who, as a young girl, played the role of the supposed spirit Rosalie. Her father, a Mr Mortimer, previously only referred to as Mr X, had been defrauding a wealthy French widow, who was desperate to contact the spirit of her dead daughter. The Mortimers persuaded their young daughter to play the role of a silent (and naked) spirit. Price, when invited to join a séance, had taped up the windows and sprinkled powder around the entrance, but apparently had been fooled by the cunning Mr Mortimer having installed a trap somewhere in the room with a well-lubricated and silent hinge so, on hearing a particular trigger phrase, the young girl could slip silently in or out the room in the near total darkness.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top