• We have updated the guidelines regarding posting political content: please see the stickied thread on Website Issues.

Conan Doyle's Most Curious Case?

TheQuixote

Gone But Not Forgotten
(ACCOUNT RETIRED)
Joined
Sep 25, 2003
Messages
3,268
From: http://www.siracd.com/life_case1.shtml

It was a moment straight out of a Sherlock Holmes novel. In January of 1907 Conan Doyle walked into the lobby of a hotel. He was late for an appointment. He was to meet with a man who was trying to clear his name. As Conan Doyle entered the lobby he spotted the man he was looking for, George Edalji. In a flash Conan Doyle knew that Edalji was innocent of the crime for which he’d served three years in prison.

George Edalji grew up in Great Wyrley, northwest of Birmingham. His father was a Parsee Indian who had converted to the Church of England and become a vicar. Reverend Edalji married an English woman and together they had three children, including George.

The Edalji family endured much racial intolerance. There was name-calling and practical jokes. In 1888 there were also anonymous, disturbing letters. A disgruntled servant of the Edalji family confessed to sending the letters.

However in 1892 another series of letters began. This time sixteen-year-old George was accused of being the culprit by local law enforcement. At the time George was a student at the Walsall Grammar School. He was considered an excellent student. No reason or evidence was given for the accusations against him. The letters ceased soon after George was accused of writing them and the matter was dropped.

In 1903 something much more troubling happened in the Great Wyrley area. Sheep, cows and horses were being killed. The animals were mutilated in the middle of the night. Long, shallow cuts to the stomach caused the animals to bleed to death.

The anonymous letters began again. The letters taunted the police and named the perpetrator of the crimes. George Edalji was named as the person behind of the hideous crimes.

By this time Edalji was a successful solicitor. While it was true that he didn’t seem to have many friends that seemed to be the worst that could be said of him.

Nevertheless evidence was gathered and a trial was held. George Edalji, vicar’s son and former solicitor, was found guilty and sentenced to seven years’ hard labor.

Not everyone who was aware of the case was convinced that justice had been done. A petition was organized to protest Edalji’s conviction and to press for his release. Ten thousand people signed the petition. Because of the publicity Edalji was released after three years. No reason was given for his release, his name was not cleared and no compensation was given for the three years of imprisonment.

While Edalji was happy for his freedom he couldn’t practice as a solicitor because of the conviction. He also thought he should receive some sort of compensation for all the time he’d lost and everything he had to endure. Since he hadn’t had much luck with the legal system, Edalji took his case to the press. He published an account of the entire matter.

Conan Doyle read about the Edalji case and felt compelled to act. In December of 1906 he began to investigate the matter and everything he found confirmed his initial feelings that an innocent man had been convicted.

As he reviewed the facts it seemed to Conan Doyle that the evidence was overwhelming. Edalji was innocent. The bloody razors found in the Edalji home were later discovered to be merely rusty razors. The handwriting expert who testified that Edalji’s handwriting matched the writing on the taunting letters was discovered to have made a serious mistake on another case causing an innocent man to be convicted. The mud on George’s boots was of a different soil type than that of the field where the last mutilation took place. The killings and letters continued after Edalji was prosecuted.

And then there was the final piece of evidence that Conan Doyle gathered. The evidence that he saw in an instant the first time he set eyes on George Edalji. Conan Doyle stated, “He had come to my hotel by appointment, but I had been delayed, and he was passing the time by reading the paper. I recognized my man by his dark face, so I stood and observed him. He held the paper close to his eyes and rather sideways, proving not only a high degree of myopia, but marked astigmatism. The idea of such a man scouring fields at night and assaulting cattle while avoiding the watching police was ludicrous . . . There, in a single physical defect, lay the moral certainty of his innocence . . . “

Conan Doyle wrote a series of articles for the Daily Telegraph about the Edalji case. He outlined everything in great detail. These articles caught the public’s attention and that caught the attention of the British government. At that time there was no procedure for a retrial so a there was a private committee meeting to consider the matter. In the spring of 1907 the committee decided that Edalji was innocent of the mutilations, but still found him guilty of writing the anonymous letters.

Conan Doyle found anything less than a finding of innocent on all charges a miscarriage of justice, however the decision made a huge difference for Edalji. The Law Society readmitted him. Edalji was once again able to practice as a solicitor.

It is important to note that partially as a result of this case the Court of Criminal Appeal was established in 1907. So not only did Conan Doyle help George Edalji, his work helped to establish a way to correct other miscarriages of justice.

For more info

Wikipedia Link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_Conan_Doyle

and

http://www.sherlockiana.net/books/rev/truecrime.html

.......................................................................................
As far as I'm aware, the person/persons who carried out the cattle mutilation is still unknown. Does anyone have any further information regarding this case?
 
I read of this case many years ago. The article was very similar to the above, focussing on the Conan Doyle involvement. I am scouring the mind to come up with what book it was in. If I do remember I will post it here, the book might have other sources, press reports, etc. that you could follow up.
 
It was also covered in FT in a "horse-ripping" special issue a few years ago.
 
Have just found this article on an online archive:

I have placed emphasis on certain paragraphs.

Death recalls gang-terror case

Originally published: June 23, 1953

Almost 50 years after he was wrongly accused of being responsible for the series of Wyrley Gang outrages, which terrorised people in a wide area of Staffordshire, Mr George Edalji has died at Welwyn Garden City, aged 77.

It was on August 18, 1903, that Mr Edalji, a young solicitor practising in Birmingham and living with his father, the Rev Shapurji Edalji, then vicar of Great Wyrley, was arrested and charged with mutilating and killing a horse.

At Staffordshire quarter Sessions, two months later, he was found guilty and sentenced to seven years penal servitude. He served three years of the sentence before an agitation set up by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, the novelist, and others resulted in an enquiry which led to his release and the grant of a free pardon, but the Home Secretary refused him compensation on the ground that he had contributed to the miscarriage of justice.

Mr Edalji was readmitted to the Law Society and practised as a solicitor in London. He was unmarried.

His death on June 17 came within a few days of the death of Mr J.H. Hall, formerly superintendant of Wednesbury, who, as a police officer, took a big part in later investigations.

Many of the strange incidents which excited public attention over a period of years at the beginning of the century were associated wiith the activities of the Wyrley gang, described as "the terror that walks by night."

First of these events was in 1888, when threatening anonymous letters were received at Great Wyrley vicarage by the Edalji family. A servant was arrested and bound over.

Between 1892 and 1895 there was a second outbreak of anonymous letters, many of which were sent to the vicarage and showed great hatred of the Edalji family, who were also the victims of a series of hoaxes.

On February 1, 1903, the first of a series of brutal attacks on horses, sheep and cows occured at Cheslyn Hay. Other instances came on May, June and August of the same year, and at the same time letters were received by people unconnected with the crimes, by the police and by the editor of the Express and Star, all signed "G.H. Darby, captain of the Wyrley gang".

Some of these letters stated when and where cattle would be maimed, and the crimes were duly committed, sommetimes wiithin a short distance of police patrols. No sounds were heard except occasionally the gallop of animals in the field.

After the conviction of Mr Edalji the outrages continued while he was in custody and twice after his release when he was far from the scene.

The mystery remained unsolved, but in 1934 a man, now dead, was convicted of sending anonymous letter signed "G.H. Darby." It was in this aspect of the case that ex-Superintendant Hall was concerned.

One of the oplice who night after night laid raps for the Great Wyrley cattle maimer was the late police constable J. Bradley, who died recently at Springhead, Sedgley.

He related to the Express and Star on one occasion how officers kept weary and wet vigils for the cattle maimer, whoever he was.

"We found beasts maimed within a few feet of where vigilannt police were waiting but didn't catch him," said police constable Bradlley.

"It was like the hunt for Jack the Ripper, whose name was in everyone's mouth when I was young."

http://content.blackcountry.com/mm/publish/article_308.php
 
I can also thoroughly recommend the book "Arthur & George" by Julian Barnes.
 
I can also thoroughly recommend the book "Arthur & George" by Julian Barnes.

Me too.

There's also a BBC radio play, which predates Arthur & George. I had a vague memory of it some months ago when hunting for radio drama to listen to while in far away countries of which we know little, and managed to track it down on YouTube:

 
Back
Top