http://www.stuffmagazine.com/articles/html/article_817.html
see also: http://www.metafilter.com/mefi/36607 for more links
Mystery River
College students are turning up dead in the Mississippi. Police say they drowned. Locals fear it's the work of a serial killer. Our investigation has turned up a potential suspect.
Stuff, October 2004
By Annemarie Conte
Rain pours down on a cold Wisconsin night as a man fights the current of the Mississippi River. It’s almost 2 A.M., and Jeff Geesey, a college sophomore in La Crosse, Wisconsin, is drunk. Lightning illuminates the sky as Geesey struggles in the violent currents until his arms and legs go numb. Exhausted, he succumbs to hypothermia and disappears beneath the water.
Back on campus, Geesey’s friends wonder why he hasn’t returned to the dorm at the University of Wisconsin-La Crosse. As word spreads, a rumor sweeps the town: Geesey is another victim of a serial killer who stalks young men too intoxicated to fend him off. The bodies of the other three alleged victims had turned up in the river during the past two years.
A bloodhound is used to search for Geesey. After four weeks, the dog hits on a scent that indicates Geesey experienced trauma in several locations. Someone apparently drove him more than a mile from the bar-heavy Third Street area to Niedbalski Bridge. Penny Bell, the bloodhound’s handler, says the dog found Geesey’s blood. “She was licking the pavement. But there was no forensics follow-up.”
La Crosse police chief Ed Kondracki remains skeptical. “Things she said those dogs could do, dogs can’t do,” he says.
On May 22, 1999, 41 days after Geesey vanished, two fishermen found his body. The medical examiner classified the manner of death as undetermined, but unofficially, some police officers consider it a suicide, based on four shallow self-inflicted scars on Geesey’s arms. But Geesey’s angry father says that a psychological evaluation determined that when Jeff cut himself, he was upset—but not suicidal.
To the students and the locals of La Crosse, the notion that four strapping young men drowned in the river in a span of two years seemed like too much of a coincidence—even if they all were drunk. On campus and in town, the serial-killer theory grew in popularity.
But just as the bodies in the river faded from the public’s consciousness, the town was shaken by the disappearance of a fifth young man, Jared Dion, on April 10, 2004. His corpse was found in the river five days later. Amid a public frenzy, La Crosse cops quickly deemed his death accidental. But a recent Stuff investigation determined that police might have too readily dismissed the possibility that a killer or killers were responsible for some or all of the deaths, simply because it seemed unlikely. Even worse, they failed to thoroughly investigate any of the deaths as possible homicides.
One week after Dion’s body turned up, an explosive La Crosse town meeting was broadcast live on local TV. Residents received cheers as they grilled a panel of police, university representatives and health officials.
Dan Marcou, a La Crosse police lieutenant and an uncle of one of the five dead boys, fought back tears as he chastised the crowd. “The La Crosse police department investigated all of these [deaths] thoroughly,” Marcou says. “I have to listen to people applaud at the thought that my nephew was killed by a serial killer. This community is like an alcoholic. It would rather think a killer is loose than admit that it’s got a drinking problem.”
see also: http://www.metafilter.com/mefi/36607 for more links