• We have updated the guidelines regarding posting political content: please see the stickied thread on Website Issues.

Hikikomori: Japan's Missing Million

A

Anonymous

Guest
Japanese withdraw from society.

Friday, 18 October, 2002, 08:31 GMT 09:31 UK
Japan: The Missing Million

By Phil Rees
Reporting from Japan for Correspondent

Teenage boys in Japan's cities are turning into modern hermits - never leaving their rooms. Pressure from schools and an inability to talk to their families are suggested causes. Phil Rees visits the country to see what the "hikikomori" condition is all about.
I knew him only as the boy in the kitchen.

His mother, Yoshiko, wouldn't tell me his name, fearful that neighbours in this Tokyo suburb might discover her secret.

Her son is 17 years old. Three years ago he was unhappy in school and began to play truant.

Then one day, he walked into the family's kitchen, shut the door and refused to leave.

Families adjust

Since then, he hasn't left the room or allowed anyone in.

Sprawling city suburbs harbour hikikomori sufferers

The family have since built a new kitchen - at first they had to cook on a makeshift stove or eat take away food.

His mother takes meals to his door three times a day.

The toilet is adjacent to the kitchen, but he only baths once every six months.

Yoshiko showed me pictures of her son before his retreat into isolation; he was a plump, cheerful young teenager, with no symptoms of mental illness.

Bullying tipped the balance

Then a classmate taunted him with anonymous hate letters and scrawled abusive graffiti about him in the schoolyard.

The boy in the kitchen suffers from a social disorder known in Japan as hikikomori, which means to withdraw from society.

One psychologist has described the condition as an "epidemic", which now claims more than a million sufferers in their late teens and twenties.

The trigger is usually an event at school, such as bullying, an exam failure or a broken romance.
Dr Grubb: "I'd knock the door down and walk in"


Unique condition

Dr Henry Grubb, a psychologist from the University of Maryland in the United States, is preparing the first academic study to be published outside Japan.

He says that young people the world over fear school or suffer agoraphobia, but hikikomori is a specific condition that doesn't exist elsewhere.

"It's really hard to get a handle on this" he told me, "there's nothing like this in the West."

Dr Grubb is also surprised by the passive, softly, softly approach followed by parents and counsellors in Japan.

"If my child was inside that door and I didn't see him, I'd knock the door down and walk in. Simple. But in Japan, everybody says give it time, it's a phase or he'll grow out of it."


'Crammer' schools wield heavy pressure

If children refuse to attend school, social workers or the courts rarely get involved.

Most consider hikikomori a problem within the family, rather than a psychological illness.

Historical origins

Japan's leading hikikomori psychiatrist, Dr Tamaki Saito, believes the cause of the problem lies within Japanese history and society.

Traditional poetry and music often celebrate the nobility of solitude.

And until the mid-nineteenth century, Japan had cut itself off from the outside world for 200 years.

More recently, Dr Saito points to the relationship between mothers and their sons.

Most hikikomori sufferers are male, often the eldest son.


Dr Saito is critical of the mother and son relationship

"In Japan, mothers and sons often have a symbiotic, co-dependent relationship.

Mothers will care for their sons until they become 30 or 40 years old."

After a period of time - usually a matter of years - some re-enter society.

The mystery remains

Increasingly, clinics are opening, offering a half-way house for recovering sufferers.

Another sufferer, Tadashi, spent four years without leaving his home.

Two years ago, he sought help and now has a part time job making doughnuts.

Tadashi is slowly re-entering society.

He still fears meeting strangers and is petrified that neighbours will find out that he once suffered from the disorder.

Hiroshi Sasaki's self imposed exile has shattered family life

But what bothers him most is not understanding why he lost four years of his life.

"I want to know the reasons," he told me. "You could say it's related to Japanese traditions.

"I just don't know. I suppose people are still trying to find out what hikikomori is all about."

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/correspondent/2334893.stm
:eek!!!!: :confused:
sakina
 
There was something exactly the same as this in the tate magazine, only: The reason was allegedly to make perfectly smooth balls of mud, called something or other, and no one knew why :WTF: .
When i get home, i'll type it up.
 
Unique or not, it is clearly an anxiety disorder. There have been very
high rates of youth suicides in Japan for many years, usually blamed
on the highly competitve school system and bullying.

I am a bit dubious about the deeper cultural causes mentioned in the
report. How much traditional culture do young people absorb? The
willingness of mothers to go on serving them is probably the key
fact.

Now I'm going into my study, I may be some time. :(
 
Why choose the damn kitchen though? Surely the bedroom would have been more logical. Or perhaps in his case they may be an anorexia dimension to the condition. Poor sod needs help not patience. If I'd allowed Hubcap to fester in his bedroom when he had his last breakdown (as he wanted to do), he'd still be there now. Instead I dragged him into the shopping centre every day and made him stay there till he realised he wasn't going to die of anxiety, and I hope he would do the same for me.
 
Seems to me to that it's related to a breakdownbut for some reasomn takes on a particular form in Japan.

And why the kitchen? Well why not? If you're going to baracade yourself into a room then any room is as good as another.
 
I think the syndrome is the withdrawal rather than the choice of
room. This particular lad chose the kitchen, possibly because he
felt safest there?

The documentary is on BBC2 in five minutes. But I'm going to hide
in the kitchen. :(
 
It can't be that hard to knock the door down, surely? Their kitchen can't be in a safe! Poor boy must be seriously unhealthy by now, if only from the lack of hygiene. If his family really loved him, they'd get him out of there and give him a hug.
 
I am speechless at the japanese crammer schools........ffs, making kids take exams until them get them right and only then letting them go to bed....then getting them up at dawn to take more exams!!!! sleep deprivation, mindless repitive tasks, isn't that the tactics employed by cults???? Poor kids, somebody needs to give the education system a kick up the butt.
 
Blueswidow said:
I am speechless at the japanese crammer schools........ffs, making kids take exams until them get them right and only then letting them go to bed....then getting them up at dawn to take more exams!!!! sleep deprivation, mindless repitive tasks, isn't that the tactics employed by cults???? Poor kids, somebody needs to give the education system a kick up the butt.

yep its absolutely mindless and produces zombies. Uk seems to think its a good idea at the moment too!
 
i have to say that not all jap parents are so horrible as to comit this type of child abuse. As always extreems make it to telly.
 
Having watched the thing on telly about this tonight I can sort of see how it happens. I have fallen into periods of depression before as have most people. At the time, if I could have got away with staying in my bedroom and not coming out I probably would have. Since I have to pay my rent and eat and stuff this would be impossible. In a society where someone such as your mother will look after you and feed you, I can really see people hiding away from the world and not coming out.
 
I live in Japan, what do you lot want to know?

Materialism is to blame, in my opinion, at least for a lot of youth problems.

These hikkokomori guys fill their rooms with so much technology that they don't need/want to go outside. That's the point, they're the kings of their own little world in there. There are entire industries devoted to feeding these guys' indulgent obsessions and fixations (voyeurism, underage girl complexes, warped comic books, animated films, gadget collecting, toy hoarding, etc., etc.).

Nobody goes geek better than the Japanese.

They're crushed with education and stifling parental expectation.
Boys have everything layed on for them by their mothers, its a direct borrowing from the Chinese. They're every wish is pandered to and all eccentricities and selfishness tolerated. This is because, parents know, that sooner or later the system will strip them of much of their freedom, so they let them enjoy it while they can. Many however, never enter the world of adulthood.
Societal conformism as evidenced in advertising and heavy image bombardment here is unparalleled the world over. Not surprisingly, many buckle under. The answer is to withdraw, because that is the only acceptable avenue of escape on offer: the Japanese are paranoically avoidant of public spectacle. Instead of going out of their minds running wild in the streets (this has happened a few times though) most borderlines simply retreat into a cave of electronically enriched seclusion - with their aging but non-complaining (as per Confucian virtue) mothers providing their domestic comforts.

It's nothing new. It's just getting worse too.
 
Sinica said:
There are entire industries devoted to feeding these guys' indulgent obsessions and fixations (voyeurism, underage girl complexes, warped comic books, animated films, gadget collecting, toy hoarding, etc., etc.).

Why are Japanese men obsessed with young girls? And who loves the Japanese women when they get to their 20's (or 30's even)?
 
This syndrome is similar to the problem my son has ( only I'm not looking after him 'til he's thirty ! Sod that ! )
 
lutzman said:
Why are Japanese men obsessed with young girls? And who loves the Japanese women when they get to their 20's (or 30's even)?

I googled "japanese obsession with underage girls" and one of the returns included this:

The Japanese obsession with young girls is really not any "weirder" than the American obsession with big breasts if you look at it clearly. Virtually every culture on Earth has something similar but some are more interested in hiding them than others. There is no way to explain or defend them.

Also, the legally enforced concept of "underage" in Japan is significantly lower than in the USA. ...


Now that was specific to anime and I suspect the author has a thing about underage girls, too, given the tone of his response.

I also found this:

HENTAI: Heh...anime porn. This has actually bloomed in popularity with the internet. You've probably gotten Hentai spam in the mail. The most common characteristic is underage girls with no pubic hair. This isn't because the Japanese are pedophiles, like most think. It's mostly because until recently, Japanese Law stated that no pubic hair could be shown on television or in print. So in order to keep the adult industry alive, they found ways around it. In direct translation, "Hentai" means "Perversion". Hence, you'll find very common themes of S&M, Domination, and Rape fantasies in Hentai.

And this:

it might be culturally impossible for Americans to understand this obsession. While no one condones sex with a minor in Japan, the Japanese idea of what constitutes a minor is very different from ours (Japanese law gives conflicting ages of consent; it varies from 13-17 years of age in different locales. However, a new law enacted in 1999 makes it illegal to have sex with anyone under 18 in certain circumstances). Also, the practice of middle-aged men having sex with very young girls isn't demonized there as it is in the U.S. In many circles, such girls are considered lucky to have a patron.

GIVE ME A BREAK!
 
Sick'O's--who like that xxx stuff

owning a comic store for years I get asked for japonese comics alot ,and carry some..there are soooo..many types and I have to screen them all..a head-ache..It's ok for the over 18 folks and what not, I just put them in their boxes , they order in advance..but people walk in and just ask for that type of stuff ,comics,movies , toys..Its so vast!! and its popular.I'M not going to ever carry the xxx stuff though..I think marvel,d.c. archie,dark horse,etc..are a-ok and better
 
Here's a newer, extremely long article on hikikomori from the New York Times.

I'll just paste the first page...? Tough call.
Shutting Themselves In

By MAGGIE JONES
Published: January 15, 2006

One morning when he was 15, Takeshi shut the door to his bedroom, and for the next four years he did not come out. He didn't go to school. He didn't have a job. He didn't have friends. Month after month, he spent 23 hours a day in a room no bigger than a king-size mattress, where he ate dumplings, rice and other leftovers that his mother had cooked, watched TV game shows and listened to Radiohead and Nirvana. "Anything," he said, "that was dark and sounded desperate."

I met Takeshi outside Tokyo not long ago, shortly after he finally left his parents' house to join a job-training program called New Start. He was wiry, with a delicate face, tousled, dyed auburn hair and the intensity of a hungry college freshman. "Don't laugh, but musicians really helped me, especially Radiohead," he told me through an interpreter, before scribbling some lyrics in English in my notebook. "That's what encouraged me to leave my room."

The night Takeshi and I met, we were at one of New Start's three-times-a-week potluck dinners at a community center where the atmosphere was like a school dorm's - a dartboard nailed to the wall over a large dining table, a worn couch and overstuffed chairs in front of a TV blaring a soccer match. About two dozen guys lounged on chairs or sat on tatami mats, slurping noodles and soup and talking movies and music. Most were in their 20's. And many had stories very much like Takeshi's.

Next to us was Shuichi, who, like Takeshi, asked that I use only his first name to protect his privacy. He was 20, wore low-slung jeans on his lanky body and a 1970's Rod Stewart shag and had dreams of being a guitarist. Three years ago, he dropped out of high school and became a recluse for a miserable year before a counselor persuaded him to join New Start. Behind him a young man sat on the couch wearing small wire-frame glasses and a shy smile. He ducked his head as he spoke, and his voice was so quiet that I had to lean in to hear him. After years of being bullied at school and having no friends, Y.S., who asked to be identified by his initials, retreated to his room at age 14, and proceeded to watch TV, surf the Internet and build model cars - for 13 years. When he finally left his room one April afternoon last year, he had spent half of his life as a shut-in. Like Takeshi and Shuichi, Y.S. suffered from a problem known in Japan as hikikomori, which translates as "withdrawal" and refers to a person sequestered in his room for six months or longer with no social life beyond his home. (The word is a noun that describes both the problem and the person suffering from it and is also an adjective, like "alcoholic.") Some hikikomori do occasionally emerge from their rooms for meals with their parents, late-night runs to convenience stores or, in Takeshi's case, once-a-month trips to buy CD's. And though female hikikomori exist and may be undercounted, experts estimate that about 80 percent of the hikikomori are male, some as young as 13 or 14 and some who live in their rooms for 15 years or more.

South Korea and Taiwan have reported a scattering of hikikomori, and isolated cases may have always existed in Japan. But only in the last decade and only in Japan has hikikomori become a social phenomenon. Like anorexia, which has been largely limited to Western cultures, hikikomori is a culturebound syndrome that thrives in one particular country during a particular moment in its history.

As the problem has become more widespread in Japan, an industry has sprung up around it. There are support groups for parents, psychologists who specialize in it (including one who counsels shut-ins via the Internet) and several halfway programs like New Start, offering dorms and job training. For all the attention, though, hikikomori remains confounding. The Japanese public has blamed everything from smothering mothers to absent, overworked fathers, from school bullying to the lackluster economy, from academic pressure to video games. "I sometimes wonder whether or not I understand this issue," confessed Shinako Tsuchiya, a member of Parliament, one afternoon in her Tokyo office. She has led a study group on hikikomori, but most of her colleagues aren't interested, and the government has yet to allocate funds. "They don't understand how serious it is."

That may be in part because the scope of the problem is frustratingly elusive. A leading psychiatrist claims that one million Japanese are hikikomori, which, if true, translates into roughly 1 percent of the population. Even other experts' more conservative estimates, ranging between 100,000 and 320,000 sufferers, are alarming, given how dire the consequences may be. As a hikikomori ages, the odds that he'll re-enter the world decline. Indeed, some experts predict that most hikikomori who are withdrawn for a year or more may never fully recover. That means that even if they emerge from their rooms, they either won't get a full-time job or won't be involved in a long-term relationship. And some will never leave home. In many cases, their parents are now approaching retirement, and once they die, the fate of the shut-ins - whose social and work skills, if they ever existed, will have atrophied - is an open question.

The full article here: http://www.nytimes.com/2006/01/15/magazine/15japanese.html
 
Spotted this story about a similar phenomenon in Seoul, South Korea:

Nearly 130k Young Shut-Ins in Seoul: Data​

Difficulty finding a job or loss of job was the leading cause of social isolation.

Published 10 February 2023 By TK

According to a study released on January 18 by Seoul’s city government, as many as 129k Seoul residents in their 20s and 30s - or 5 percent of Seoul’s young adult demographic - are isolated 고립 or shut-in 은둔, respectively defined as spending six months or more in mental or physical isolation, and rarely leaving the house for six months or more. Seoul conducted the study from May to December 2022.

Difficulty finding a job or loss of job was the leading cause (45.5 percent) of young people becoming isolated or shut-in. This demographic tends to self-identify as low income (64.7 percent) and in poor health (43.2 percent) relative to the Seoul residents in their 20s and 30s generally (of whom 31.4 percent self-identify as low income and 14.2% as in poor health.) Among the isolated or shut-in young people, 57.6 percent said they were suffering from severe depression.

Seoul city government’s survey is the first of its kind in South Korea, conducted in order to design a social services program tailored to assist in job searching and mental health counseling.


SOURCE:
https://www.blueroofpolitics.com/post/nearly-130k-young-shut-ins-in-seoul-data/
 
I struggle to find much wrong with this

"...mental or physical isolation, and rarely leaving the house for six months or more."

This can have profound effects on the individuals themselves as well as society as a whole.

If, as seems likely, the phenomenon is growing, governments certainly need to address it.
 
"...mental or physical isolation, and rarely leaving the house for six months or more."

This can have profound effects on the individuals themselves as well as society as a whole.

If, as seems likely, the phenomenon is growing, governments certainly need to address it.
I feel terrible if I don't get fresh air and exercise for at least an hour or two every day, even if it's raining and/or cold.

I wonder if they would do the same without access to the internet?
 
Back
Top