- Joined
- Sep 19, 2005
- Messages
- 264
I have thought much on this very subject, if it can be thought of as just one subject, rather than many. I think there are many contributors:
#1: Detachment from reality. This is perhaps partly due to the internet making people have to deal with others face-to-face less, as it grows more and more prominent. A larger factor, I believe, is the world becoming increasingly co-dependent. We often rely on others completely for survival. Not neighbors and local businesses, but people from across the nation or from other nations. The world is becoming a house of cards that will cause great suffering if part of it collapses. If (hypothetically) the government collapsed tomorrow and there was suddenly no police, no hospitals, no imports from out of town, no public schools, no road repairs, etc, how many people would be able to survive, I wonder? I suspect it would not be many.
#2: Someone connected school sports and gangs. A thought occured to me while watching Cool Hand Luke -- in that movie, the two people who were feuding were given boxing gloves and allowed to get it out of their systems. Now they would be allowed to stew, eventually leading to more serious violence. School sports perhaps give an outlet for a young male's competitive nature, and the human wish to be a part of something. It also allows them to work out their aggression in a harmless manner, while learning to be respectful to their rivals (if they have a good coach), as the Cool Hand Luke example possibly has something to do with. The current rapper-type gang mentality was becoming fashionable the last year I was in high school. The rappers (probably not intentionally) really did glamorize it, sort of like how a war movie can glamorize war, so that's part of it.
#3: Gender roles. I'm all for gender equality and women not being held back by their gender. However, I feel that there are likely unforeseen and subtle side effects of this. Gender roles have an evolutionary purpose, and as we outgrow our evolutionary dictates, we acquire deadend hard-coded behavior, such as the aforementioned aggressive, competitive urges that sports help curb. Feminine equality is relatively new and will likely cause some waves as it settles in. I've noticed an increasing trend of women being treated like meat, and worse the glamorization of being a sex object. Sometimes voluntarily making oneself a sexual object is seen as empowering. I find this very disturbing.
#4: Lack of community. As populations grow, and traveling long distances for work or school becomes more commonplace, we begin to lose our sense of community. In a large city, I feel crime is likely to be higher, because I think people are more likely to rob someone they don't know, or hardly know; a well-known neighbor would be safer. Around college, families and friends break up and spread across the country. The internet also contributes to not getting to know locals. As we become a world community, we lose close-knit local communities.
#5: Fear and ignorance. The cornerstones of barbarism. We live in fear of terrorists. We live in fear of upsetting people, due to political correctness and outrageous lawsuits. In the US you can sue someone over something ridiculous and are fairly likely to win. Political correctness is kin to censorship. And with things like the push for Creationism to be taught in schools being taken seriously, surely we are on the brink of barbarism if we are not already there.
Those are my thoughts. The question is, what to do about them? If nothing else, live the way you think people should live. Don't lie, cheat, or steal. Be friendly and polite and respectful to all, even those who are not so to you. Lead by example. Meet your neighbors and buy from local farmers' markets. Wounds this deep can only heal with much time.
Robert E. Howard, creator of Conan, seemingly felt that barbarism was the natural state and civilization was inherently flawed. He said in a letter, "... [W]hen a civilization begins to decay and die, the only thing men or women think about is gratification of their body's desires. They become preoccupied with sex." Sounds like the modern US to me!
Edit: I believe we are well into the decline of Western civilization, and I don't think the question is how do we stop or curb it, but how do we recover after it reaches its inevitable conclusion, possibly in our lifetimes?
#1: Detachment from reality. This is perhaps partly due to the internet making people have to deal with others face-to-face less, as it grows more and more prominent. A larger factor, I believe, is the world becoming increasingly co-dependent. We often rely on others completely for survival. Not neighbors and local businesses, but people from across the nation or from other nations. The world is becoming a house of cards that will cause great suffering if part of it collapses. If (hypothetically) the government collapsed tomorrow and there was suddenly no police, no hospitals, no imports from out of town, no public schools, no road repairs, etc, how many people would be able to survive, I wonder? I suspect it would not be many.
#2: Someone connected school sports and gangs. A thought occured to me while watching Cool Hand Luke -- in that movie, the two people who were feuding were given boxing gloves and allowed to get it out of their systems. Now they would be allowed to stew, eventually leading to more serious violence. School sports perhaps give an outlet for a young male's competitive nature, and the human wish to be a part of something. It also allows them to work out their aggression in a harmless manner, while learning to be respectful to their rivals (if they have a good coach), as the Cool Hand Luke example possibly has something to do with. The current rapper-type gang mentality was becoming fashionable the last year I was in high school. The rappers (probably not intentionally) really did glamorize it, sort of like how a war movie can glamorize war, so that's part of it.
#3: Gender roles. I'm all for gender equality and women not being held back by their gender. However, I feel that there are likely unforeseen and subtle side effects of this. Gender roles have an evolutionary purpose, and as we outgrow our evolutionary dictates, we acquire deadend hard-coded behavior, such as the aforementioned aggressive, competitive urges that sports help curb. Feminine equality is relatively new and will likely cause some waves as it settles in. I've noticed an increasing trend of women being treated like meat, and worse the glamorization of being a sex object. Sometimes voluntarily making oneself a sexual object is seen as empowering. I find this very disturbing.
#4: Lack of community. As populations grow, and traveling long distances for work or school becomes more commonplace, we begin to lose our sense of community. In a large city, I feel crime is likely to be higher, because I think people are more likely to rob someone they don't know, or hardly know; a well-known neighbor would be safer. Around college, families and friends break up and spread across the country. The internet also contributes to not getting to know locals. As we become a world community, we lose close-knit local communities.
#5: Fear and ignorance. The cornerstones of barbarism. We live in fear of terrorists. We live in fear of upsetting people, due to political correctness and outrageous lawsuits. In the US you can sue someone over something ridiculous and are fairly likely to win. Political correctness is kin to censorship. And with things like the push for Creationism to be taught in schools being taken seriously, surely we are on the brink of barbarism if we are not already there.
Those are my thoughts. The question is, what to do about them? If nothing else, live the way you think people should live. Don't lie, cheat, or steal. Be friendly and polite and respectful to all, even those who are not so to you. Lead by example. Meet your neighbors and buy from local farmers' markets. Wounds this deep can only heal with much time.
Robert E. Howard, creator of Conan, seemingly felt that barbarism was the natural state and civilization was inherently flawed. He said in a letter, "... [W]hen a civilization begins to decay and die, the only thing men or women think about is gratification of their body's desires. They become preoccupied with sex." Sounds like the modern US to me!
Edit: I believe we are well into the decline of Western civilization, and I don't think the question is how do we stop or curb it, but how do we recover after it reaches its inevitable conclusion, possibly in our lifetimes?