• We have updated the guidelines regarding posting political content: please see the stickied thread on Website Issues.

A Good Read: Book Suggestions & Recommendations

Have you ever read the Peake books...The Gormenghast trilogy..? I've been meaning to read them for years now.
Never got around to Peake's books but I did read a memoir of him by his wife.

Been away since early-ish Feb. -- only lately back, and seen these references. I tried the first in the "Gormenghast" series a couple of times, and found it, "right off the bat", unreadable -- was unable to get more than a couple of dozen pages in. I'm hard to please, fiction-wise: there are a fair number of authors who do nothing for me; but there are so many people whose intelligence and taste I respect, who love those authors -- that I tend to feel that the fault must lie with me. "Gormenghast" just struck me as pointless whimsy-witter; a parallel for me is Pratchett, whose stuff I find lead-heavy and totally un-funny and un-engaging. My loss, probably...

It has occurred to me that J.K. Rowling may have got some of her ideas for Hogwarts, from "Gormenghast" -- a spooky castle / mansion-type imposing "pile", dwelt in by eccentric and crotchety professors, and surrounded by darkling woods inhabited by weird creatures and kind-of managed by colourful gamekeeper / poacher types -- Peake's "Flay, the long man of the woods", and Rowling's Hagrid. No adverse criticism implied, of Rowling for this: authors have been borrowing from each other for as long as there have been authors.
 
I can see the possible JKRowling connection. I imagine that The Gormenghast trilogy has influenced other authors as well. I'm about 25 pages in right now...and taking a break to read Sandman Slim- The Kill Society.
I'll go back to Titus Groan soon. It's well written but can be tedious at times...and it seems like an inside joke for the authors own pleasure at times.
 
...Arthur C. Clarke, Childhood’s End. In for a penny, in for a pound, as they say. And once again, why haven’t they turned this into a movie?..

But they have.

INT21
 
Noticed as I read further down the comments that someone mentions this.

But I do believe that 2001 was derived from 'The Sentinel', not 'childhoods End'.

INT21
 
Stephen Erikson's Malazan Book of the Fallen 10 books, You'll either love it or hate it.

Took a while to hook me in, but am thoroughly enjoying in now, having almost completed The Gardens of The Moon. Very adult with quite a Game of Thrones-like vibe. Guess that's me committed to reading 10 large volumes of Erikson's magnum opus now - should keep me going throughout 2018.
 
"The World That Never Was: A True Story Of Dreamers, Schemers, Anarchists & Secret Agents by Alex Butterworth.

Roughly bookended by the Paris Commune and the Russian Revolution. Plenty of secret agents and agent provocateurs here, it certainly looks as if the Okhrana (Czarist Secret Police) were responsible for provoking many acts of terror and sometimes lost control of the plots they were behind. As did Scotland Yard's Special Branch when a planned assassination of minor Royals they instigated almost succeeded. Scotland Yard still refuses to release unredacted SB files from the 1890s, I wonder what they are hiding?

Some Anarchists and Socialists spent decades accusing each other of being informers/agents, much to the delight of the Okhrana. Theodore Reuss, an opera singer also "refounded the Illuminati") and paid agent of the German Police went on to become a Gnostic Bishop. Jugand-Pages was expelled from the Masons for scurrilous attacks on the Pope, he then reconciled with the RCC and exposed the Masons as a "satanic cult".

The Paris Commune provided plenty of Forteana and even earlier during the Prussian Siege. Rochefort as President of the barricades had to deal with: "7 or 8 Archimedes proposing means of destroying the besieging army". A giant hammer lifted by balloons to be dropped on the Prussians. Lions from the zoo to be set on the enemy. "Most of the ideas received were less practical" - Rochefort.

In exile after being transported to New Caledonia: "Rochefort slept badly, woken in the early hours by a friendly black chicken, he seized upon it as an auspicious sign". He subsequently escaped, it's not reported if he ate the chicken or took it as a travelling companion. And I'm only 100 pages into the book!
 
Only just got round to reading it and I can recommend Invisible Planets (trans. Ken Liu), a collection of contemporary chinese s.f. short stories.
 
Not sure if its been mentioned before. Just doing a reread of the Laundry files.

Think of a modern cross between James Bond and H.P Lovecraft. Essentially the only thing Lovecraft got wrong is he made the mythos to fluffy and nice and the titular Laundry is the secret branch of S.O.E that is responsible for keeping the general populace in the dark and dealing with any outbreaks of weird stuff.
 
Austral by Paul J. McAuley is se in Antarctica in the 22nd century, geoengineering projects have failed and the ice around the coast has melted but on the plus side the South Shetlands and the Antarctic Peninsula have become habitable. This is an SF thriller set in a frontier society involving a gengineered woman, a Huskie, whose type is discriminated against and how she gets caught up in a kidnapping. Great novel about a new Antarctica, one that seems possible, even likely.
 
Putting in a word for Christopher Fowler's, Bryant and May novels about the two ancient detectives in London's Peculiar Crimes Unit, a specialist unit for crimes that are too bizarre for everybody else and could cause public disorder. Mr May is a dapper, charming, silver fox. Mr Bryant is as eccentric as hell. likely to turn to mediums, witches and some very strange people (e.g. Punch and Judy men) as advisors on cases (BTW he reads Fortean Times). The reset of the unit are a bunch of misfits who wouldn't fit anywhere in a normal police unit. Most of the stories are in contemporary London (there's a few earlier cases) some are Fortean tinged and there's a lot about the strange myths, legends and histories of London, which almost always play a role in the solution of the crimes.
 
Thanks for the mention of those Fowler books,,,that's the kind of thing I like.
:)
 
Putting in a word for Christopher Fowler's, Bryant and May novels about the two ancient detectives in London's Peculiar Crimes Unit, a specialist unit for crimes that are too bizarre for everybody else and could cause public disorder. Mr May is a dapper, charming, silver fox. Mr Bryant is as eccentric as hell. likely to turn to mediums, witches and some very strange people (e.g. Punch and Judy men) as advisors on cases (BTW he reads Fortean Times). The reset of the unit are a bunch of misfits who wouldn't fit anywhere in a normal police unit. Most of the stories are in contemporary London (there's a few earlier cases) some are Fortean tinged and there's a lot about the strange myths, legends and histories of London, which almost always play a role in the solution of the crimes.

New to me: sounds intriguing and worth following up. (Re Mr. May: is he human; and your description, of the figure-of-speech kind -- or -- this "specialist unit" being on the Fortean scene -- is he an actual specimen of the melanistic form of the red fox [Vulpes vulpes], magically gifted with human intellect and speech ;) ?)

I being a bit of a miserable, negative so-and-so -- am thus qualifying first sentence with: feel reminded by description of these novels, of Ben Aaronovich's Rivers of London series, about the Metropolitan Police's "supernatural affairs" sub-section; much enjoyed and praised by many -- I read the first two or three, initially with enjoyment, but came to feel -- almost always a "kiss-of-death" thing for me -- that it was getting rather "mechanistically churned-out", and "box-ticking" book by book (river spirits -- tick; poltergeists -- tick; vampires -- tick): I abandoned the series. And the "bunch of misfits" element, recalls to me the fairly recent Slow Horses novel series (I forget name of author) -- spy-type thrillers whose main characters are players on that scene, in disgrace for lack of competence at their job,and kept on in a despised unit assigned to the profession's lowliest, dullest tasks. This series seems quite widely acclaimed: I tried it, thinking "maybe spy novels with a difference"; but, perversely, I find nearly all spook-and-spy fiction ditchwater-dull -- and Slow Horses proved to be no exception. I'll hope, though, that such resemblances might be superficial; and to possibly find Bryant and May, good fun.
 
Re my immediately-before post -- the Slow Horses books are by (have just looked up) a chap called Mick Herron.
 
New to me: sounds intriguing and worth following up. (Re Mr. May: is he human; and your description, of the figure-of-speech kind -- or -- this "specialist unit" being on the Fortean scene -- is he an actual specimen of the melanistic form of the red fox [Vulpes vulpes], magically gifted with human intellect and speech ;) ?)

I being a bit of a miserable, negative so-and-so -- am thus qualifying first sentence with: feel reminded by description of these novels, of Ben Aaronovich's Rivers of London series, about the Metropolitan Police's "supernatural affairs" sub-section; much enjoyed and praised by many -- I read the first two or three, initially with enjoyment, but came to feel -- almost always a "kiss-of-death" thing for me -- that it was getting rather "mechanistically churned-out", and "box-ticking" book by book (river spirits -- tick; poltergeists -- tick; vampires -- tick): I abandoned the series. And the "bunch of misfits" element, recalls to me the fairly recent Slow Horses novel series (I forget name of author) -- spy-type thrillers whose main characters are players on that scene, in disgrace for lack of competence at their job,and kept on in a despised unit assigned to the profession's lowliest, dullest tasks. This series seems quite widely acclaimed: I tried it, thinking "maybe spy novels with a difference"; but, perversely, I find nearly all spook-and-spy fiction ditchwater-dull -- and Slow Horses proved to be no exception. I'll hope, though, that such resemblances might be superficial; and to possibly find Bryant and May, good fun.

Mr May, is entirely human, silver fox as in good-looking older man who's rather a hit with the ladies. And athough there's certainly Fortean elements, the crimes are peculiar because they appear to be impossible, because of the circumstance in which the body turns up, or because the motives are incomprehensible. The apparently supernatural elements in the stories are never what they appear to be.
 
Timble2 -- thanks. I'm male -- never before encountered the term "fox" for sexually attractive person, in any context other than lady attractive to gentlemen !

Your summary in the above post, encourages me to look at these novels: feel that I could find them agreeable reading...
 
Putting in a word for Christopher Fowler's, Bryant and May novels about the two ancient detectives in London's Peculiar Crimes Unit, a specialist unit for crimes that are too bizarre for everybody else and could cause public disorder. Mr May is a dapper, charming, silver fox. Mr Bryant is as eccentric as hell. likely to turn to mediums, witches and some very strange people (e.g. Punch and Judy men) as advisors on cases (BTW he reads Fortean Times). The reset of the unit are a bunch of misfits who wouldn't fit anywhere in a normal police unit. Most of the stories are in contemporary London (there's a few earlier cases) some are Fortean tinged and there's a lot about the strange myths, legends and histories of London, which almost always play a role in the solution of the crimes.

I bought a couple of the Bryant and May books, but after initial enthusiasm I never quite managed to get my teeth into them. As I've stated before, I'm a bit of a moody reader, and my inability to get hooked says nothing about the books - which are sitting on a shelf at home, winking at me, and available for possible future exploration. I found a similar inability to engage with Ben Aaronovitch's not entirely dissimilar series.

Of another author of similarly not dissimilar books - Fred Vargas - I've had much more success (I mentioned Vargas recently when comparing the atmosphere of her work with that of the TV series Zone Blanche). I couldn't exactly tell you why. The best way I can describe it (in comparison to Aaranovitch's work, at least) is that her refusal to definitely fix her stories in a thin place, only serves to make the world seem, well, a thin place.

As far as my personal taste goes I generally prefer an ambiguous touch when it comes to modern fiction dealing with fortean issues; in the sense that we are just the other side of the otherworldly – separated from it by a partial and very fragile boundary – rather than right in the middle of it. Some reviewers use the word ethereal to describe her fiction – possibly a good one: not in the sense that she takes you to some airy fairy otherworld of the supernatural, but in the sense that a very real and recognisable world is veiled behind an almost imperceptible mist. To me it’s that ambiguity which is the key to the way I engage with the story (as well as the 'real' world); the fact that by the end of the novel you may well end up back in a place where logic has somewhat prevailed does not shake off the suspicion that you’ve been on an odd journey in a boat full of holes up a very peculiar river. (I suspect that this is the case with the Bryant and May series too.)

On a slight tangent: I’d highly recommend Christopher Fowler’s non-fiction work, The Book of Forgotten Authors – which is most informative, and very entertaining.
 
....On a slight tangent: I’d highly recommend Christopher Fowler’s non-fiction work, The Book of Forgotten Authors – which is most informative, and very entertaining.

I'd recommend that too, actually started chasing down some of the authors in it.
 
Just started reading The Anomaly by Michael Rutger.

Very enjoyable Fortean-themed thriller based around a misfit team making an X-Creatures style documentary about something creepy in a cave. Contains references to cryptozoology, ancient astronauts, giant skeletons being hidden by the Smithsonian, drink and drugs and 1970s Brit prog-rock! Great fun!

https://books.google.co.uk/books/about/The_Anomaly.html?id=UTE4DwAAQBAJ&redir_esc=y&hl=en
 
I'd recommend that too, actually started chasing down some of the authors in it.

Me too.

I should maybe have included a warning in my original recommendation: ...which is most informative, and very entertaining...and may involve buying more books.
 
I've been emailed a copy of The Best and the Brightest (1971) by David Halberstam:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Best_and_the_Brightest

So far it's a remarkably good book and would likely interest anybody who likes U.S. politics and/or conspiracy. The foreword by John McCain is (unusually--I often skip prefaces and forewords) excellent:

Screen Shot 2018-05-16 at 02.27.27.png
Screen Shot 2018-05-16 at 02.27.40.png
 
Suggestion for a good read, which I wouldn't have expected to make, follows. There seems to me to have been, especially in the recent metaphorical-couple of decades, a surfeit of historical fiction centring on William Shakespeare, and frequently taking maximum advantage of the historically dramatic times in which he lived. Said fiction, IMO of varying quality; but, one feels, getting into some danger of becoming a flogging-to-death exercise -- albeit, with the pivotal character one re whose life the historical record is scanty, offering to writers endless scope for imagination / speculation. (Most often, Will seems to be portrayed as a mild, benign sort of chap -- in contrast with many artistic geniuses who are factually recorded as having been pretty obnoxious human beings.)

Link here hopefully, to an inventory of many -- by no means all -- of such works of fiction closely involving the Bard.

http://www.goodreads.com/list/show/7731.Shakespearean_Historical_Fiction

Included here are -- for me, with weary inevitability -- quite a number of murder mysteries; and Faye Kellerman's The Quality of Mercy -- which has Shakespeare romantically involved with an Orthodox Jewish woman -- whence, we are told, The Merchant of Venice (an original and unusual premise, if nothing else: per history in one's general perception, the likelihood of a sixteenth-century dweller in England's making the close personal acquaintance of an Orthodox Jew would have been infinitesimal).

There are other fictional featurings of Mr. S., not included in the "goodreads" list. For instance, Rory Clements's series of historically-inspired thrillers, with as hero, Shakespeare's (fictitious) older brother John. Clements has John as a serious, sober individual, a secret-service operative under Sir Francis Walsingham, combating the continental / Catholic threat to Elizabeth's England; William makes regular appearances as his scatty, feckless actor brother. For my taste, Clements's stuff tends to be wearisomely one-trick-ponyish. Also not mentioned is Harry Turtledove's -- IMO
excellent -- novel Ruled Britannia , set in an alternative time-line in which the Armada has succeeded in its objective; and with as a central character, Shakespeare as we know him from our time-line -- his name the same, but his plays under different names.

I'll admit to a considerable taste for fiction of questionable great-work-type value: so was interested to find a couple of months ago -- something to which I'd hitherto been oblivious -- that Bernard Cornwell -- of "Sharpe" and other "action"-oriented novel series -- has as of 2017, been another one to hit the Shakespeare-fiction trail. (The novel concerned -- Fools and Mortals -- is included actually, in the "goodreads" list linked-to above.) My sentiments about Cornwell are mixed and rather "random": some of his series, including the Napoleonic one, I'm favourably impressed with more than not; others -- not necessarily about subjects of no interest to me -- I've found boring (instance of the latter, his American Civil War books).

Will confess that at my first sight in a bookshop a few weeks ago, of Fools and Mortals -- Cornwell's first and so far only Shakespeare-themed novel -- my thoughts were along the lines of "oh dear Lord, has this guy gone and jumped on this particular bandwagon too?" Buying and trying it turned out, however, to be irresistible; and I was pleasantly surprised. This chap does write very competently -- plus, he has for me, something of an agreeably fresh "take" on the genre. The book centres not primarily on desperate strife between mutually hostile nations / religions, or the intrigues of Elizabeth I's court (though such matters are present in the background); nor on the figuring-out of the who-and-why of murder -- it's first and foremost about the actors and their profession and its highs and lows, and skulduggery-short-of-homicide within that profession. Characters are vividly but believably drawn. The hero is Shakespeare's younger brother Richard (historical in so far as that he did have a real-life younger brother of that name) who has made his way to London, desirous of following the same occupation as his elder sibling. And Cornwell portrays Will as less of a "goody-goody" than seems to have become almost standard in this genre: his William S. is an acerbic type who -- for unknown reasons of his own -- most of the time anyway, dislikes his brother and treats him with no kindness. The novel proved for me a grand read, with a wealth of arresting happenings and lively characterisation; I find myself eager for more of such from Mr. Cornwell, with the same central cast of characters.
 
Just discovered this free PDF, haven't started reading it yet but a quick look suggests it could be a very interesting read,

The Spectral Arctic: A Cultural History of Ghosts and Dreams in Polar Exploration
Shane McCorristine | April 2018

Visitors to the Arctic enter places that have been traditionally imagined as otherworldly. This strangeness fascinated audiences in nineteenth-century Britain when the idea of the heroic explorer voyaging through unmapped zones reached its zenith. The Spectral Arctic re-thinks our understanding of Arctic exploration by paying attention to the importance of dreams and ghosts in the quest for the Northwest Passage.

The narratives of Arctic exploration that we are all familiar with today are just the tip of the iceberg: they disguise a great mass of mysterious and dimly-lit stories beneath the surface. In contrast to oft-told tales of heroism and disaster, this book reveals the hidden stories of dreaming and haunted explorers, of frozen mummies, of rescue balloons, visits to Inuit shamans, and of the entranced female clairvoyants who travelled to the Arctic in search of John Franklin’s lost expedition. Through new readings of archival documents, exploration narratives, and fictional texts, these spectral stories reflect the complex ways that men and women actually thought about the far North in the past. This revisionist historical account allows us to make sense of current cultural and political concerns in the Canadian Arctic about the location of Franklin’s ships.


The_Spectral_Arctic.jpg



https://www.ucl.ac.uk/ucl-press/browse-books/the-spectral-arctic
 
I really loved the Mythago Wood (Holdstock) books a few years ago.....and I think it was brought up here, but can anyone recommend similar books....with a mystical realism. I have read a few of Charles De Lint's books also.
 
Took a while to hook me in, but am thoroughly enjoying in now, having almost completed The Gardens of The Moon. Very adult with quite a Game of Thrones-like vibe. Guess that's me committed to reading 10 large volumes of Erikson's magnum opus now - should keep me going throughout 2018.


The trouble as I've said before is Erikson does not have a good enough editor. The first 4 or 5 books are fantastic but he then loses track of what's going on and the whole thing gets pretty unreadable. I loved his first 3 books which are easily superior to GoT's which is set on a tiny scale in comparison and is nowhere near as original.

He basically admitted in an interview that he forgets stuff that he's written and there are plot holes littered all over his more recent Malazan books because of it.

I stopped at Reaper's Gale 6 or 7. His Novella's are excellent though. Hope you have better luck. It would be interesting to see if you do or what your thoughts are.
 
Last edited:
I really loved the Mythago Wood (Holdstock) books a few years ago.....and I think it was brought up here, but can anyone recommend similar books....with a mystical realism. I have read a few of Charles De Lint's books also.


Christopher Priest perhaps? Keith Roberts Pavane, Kite world, etc. For popcorn stuff Simon R Green's Drinking Midnight Wine and Shadows Fall are funny and good alternative reality reads.
 
Back
Top