catseye
Out of focus little thingy
- Joined
- Feb 1, 2010
- Messages
- 9,579
- Location
- York
Reading a lot of IHTM-like stories from various sites and I have realised that I've got a long 'automatically discount' list, and an almost equally long 'hmmmm (one raised eyebrow) list.
For example, I almost automatically discount any story that begins either 'I woke up and saw...' or 'I know I definitely wasn't asleep, because...', and the raised eyebrow is occasioned by anything that contains the words 'it is said', or 'I later found out that someone is supposed to have died there.'
I give the stories a once-over, because I'm aware that some perfectly plausible things happen on just waking or before falling asleep, and that it's possible that someone could experience something and only later find out that the place has a history, but so many of these seem to be either misunderstandings of hypnopompic or hypnogic or sleep paralysis experiences, or just people getting twitchy and then formulating some nebulous reason as to why. The stories of an underclass woman who is supposed to have 'got pregnant and committed suicide' to account for shapes and shadows also gets the raised eyebrow, as nobody ever seems to check (and such deaths are usually recorded).
Is it just me - am I getting too sceptical for my own good?
For example, I almost automatically discount any story that begins either 'I woke up and saw...' or 'I know I definitely wasn't asleep, because...', and the raised eyebrow is occasioned by anything that contains the words 'it is said', or 'I later found out that someone is supposed to have died there.'
I give the stories a once-over, because I'm aware that some perfectly plausible things happen on just waking or before falling asleep, and that it's possible that someone could experience something and only later find out that the place has a history, but so many of these seem to be either misunderstandings of hypnopompic or hypnogic or sleep paralysis experiences, or just people getting twitchy and then formulating some nebulous reason as to why. The stories of an underclass woman who is supposed to have 'got pregnant and committed suicide' to account for shapes and shadows also gets the raised eyebrow, as nobody ever seems to check (and such deaths are usually recorded).
Is it just me - am I getting too sceptical for my own good?