There's an old story about the executive who takes an interviewee out to dinner and tells him he didn't get the job. When asked why, the executive says "You salted your food before tasting it. What if it was already salty?"
If I were that interviewee, I would have said "I eat here all the time. I know the chef makes that dish to please most people, but I like it saltier. So I take the small step of salting it myself. But now that I know you're the type of person who punishes people for their actions without bothering to find out their reasons, I would never want to work for you."