- Joined
- Jul 19, 2004
- Messages
- 29,622
- Location
- Out of Bounds
I have to strongly disagree that most SF made before 1977 was crap, there were many great works in the field made from Metropolis in the 1920s onwards, many with mindbending concepts - The Incredible Shrinking Man is one of the most cosmic movies ever made, for instance, and special effects don't hold it back at all.
At its (original) heart, SF is about speculative concept(s), not the cinematic window dressing. A film isn't good SF just because it's got ray weapons and / or fancy spaceships. Some of the best speculative SF films and TV series (e.g., Twilight Zone) have very modest - even mundane - settings and minimal special effects.
I happened to re-watch X: The Man with the X-ray Eyes (Ray Milland; 1963):
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X:_The_Man_with_the_X-ray_Eyes
... earlier this weekend. I was greatly impressed by the fact this movie focused on the ethical / moral issues associated with how one would live with, or might exploit, X-ray vision rather than one-off gags or special effects (though the film is noted for the effectiveness of its simplistic FX). To me, this is real science fiction, whereas mere space opera (no matter how sumptuously presented) is not.