Suspect's tale: God ordered grandmother, girlfriend slain
Published in the Asbury Park Press 6/10/04
By TOM TRONCONE
STAFF WRITER
OCEAN TOWNSHIP -- A man charged with the gruesome murders of his grandmother and longtime girlfriend told police he killed the women on a directive from God, authorities said yesterday.
Rosario "Russell" Miraglia III, whose last known address was a drug rehabilitation center in Newark, told authorities a wild tale about how his grandmother, Julia Miraglia, 88, was descended from subjects of a Lebanese king who was ordered by God to kill those under his rule, said Monmouth County Prosecutor John Kaye.
Miraglia, according to police, murdered and dismembered his grandmother and Leigh Martinez, 31, the mother of his young son, in the Lakeview Avenue home the women shared. The suspect considered the home the "gateway to Hell," Kaye said.
"The king was directed by God to kill all of his subjects, but some escaped," Kaye said. "The grandmother was supposedly a direct descendant of the subjects. And he had been directed by God to finish the job. . . . He was obligated to do God's will."
Authorities doubt Miraglia actually believes the story and suspect he is instead trying to lay the groundwork for an insanity defense, Kaye said.
Kaye yesterday described in detail how authorities believe Miraglia killed his grandmother and Martinez, 31, the woman with whom he has a 6-year-old son. Miraglia entered the home through an open window around 8 a.m. and went upstairs, where he confronted Martinez, Kaye said.
Investigators believe Martinez attempted a call to 911 but Miraglia had cut the phone line, and when she picked up the phone, he stabbed her with a butcher knife, Kaye said.
After either hearing or seeing the stabbing, Julia Miraglia, frail and confined to the upstairs of the home, tried to flee, but Miraglia overtook her in the first-floor foyer and stabbed her, Kaye said.
Miraglia then dismembered the bodies with a meat cleaver, cutting off the heads, hands and feet, Kaye said. Miraglia had found both implements in the house, he added.
A call to 911
A great-uncle of the suspect's then arrived at the house; the great-uncle regularly stopped by to have breakfast and watch television with Julia Miraglia. Rosario Miraglia used the man's cell phone to call police, Kaye said. When officers arrived, Miraglia was in front of the home covered in the women's blood, Kaye said.
The fact that Miraglia killed Martinez before murdering his grandmother casts doubt on the Lebanese king tale, Kaye said.
"We believe Ms. Martinez was the primary target," Kaye said.
Kaye said yesterday that he has not determined whether to seek the death penalty.
"This case has some qualities and characteristics that would make it eligible for the death penalty," Kaye said.
It was unclear last night how long Miraglia spent in the Guild Halfway House on Freeman Street in Newark, or how long before the killings he was released. He told police he was homeless at the time of the murders and had been drug- and alcohol-free for several months, Kaye said.
In the past, however, Miraglia suffered from drug dependency and had been arrested for co-caine and heroin possession, according to Kaye and court records.
A new boyfriend
On Friday, Martinez was charged with heroin possession in Asbury Park along with Jo-seph L. Cacciatore, a man de-scribed by authorities as her lover, according to criminal complaints signed against the pair.
Cacciatore, 23, of Dairy Court, Freehold Township, was arrest-ed on heroin possession charg-es again in Asbury Park on Tuesday. He had arrived at the crime scene shortly after police did, then left upon learning about the murders and was ar-rested soon after that, accord-ing to authorities and the crim-inal complaint signed against Cacciatore.
A woman answering the phone at the Cacciatore home de-clined comment.
Martinez was a 1990 graduate of Howell Township High School. A few years later, she took a job as a secretary with the Monmouth County Division of Social Services. Described by a former colleague as a "smart kid" who deplored drugs, Marti-nez put herself through Mon-mouth University, graduating in the late 1990s.
She was hired by the county as a social worker dealing with the homeless in 1999, said Mary Fenton, for whom Martinez was a secretary.
"She was a great kid," Fenton said. "Smart. A real smart kid. Very feisty. Independent. I real-ly thought she was going to go somewhere."
Martinez resigned from the job after a couple of years and moved to Arizona to live with her parents. But soon, she was back in New Jersey and her on-again, off-again romance with Miraglia was back on, ac-cording to a friend. It was not clear whether the two were still seeing one another at the time of the murder, the friend said.
Efforts to reach Martinez's fam-ily in Arizona were unsuccess-ful.
The couple's son was removed from the home by DYFS some-time last year and placed in the custody of relatives, Kaye said. He had no information on why the child was removed.
Autopsies in progress
Dr. Jay Peacock, the Mon-mouth County medical examin-er, asked Kaye for more time to complete autopsies on the two women because he has not yet been able to inspect the knife and cleaver used in the kill-ings. These are undergoing fo-rensic examination at the New Jersey State Police laboratory.
First Assistant Monmouth County Prosecutor Robert A. Honecker Jr. plans to prosecute the case, Kaye said.
Julia Miraglia and her hus-band, the late Rosario "Babe" Miraglia, were part-owners of Jimmy's Italian Restaurant in Asbury Park until they sold their shares to the current owners in the early 1990s. "Babe" Miraglia was referred to by Kaye yesterday as a long-time organized-crime associate.
Charles Houser, a biblical ex-pert from the American Bible Society, said there is nothing he can recall in the Bible about a Lebanese king killing his fol-lowers.
"I don't know of any examples of where a person hears a voice and is instructed to kill," he said. "And I don't know of any occasions where a king is in-structed to kill" his own sub-jects.
He said there are references in the Bible to "the ban," a term used when the rulers of new dynasties would kill anyone who had a claim to the throne they were overtaking.
Authorities have also not deter-mined what king or to which Bible passage Miraglia was re-ferring, Kaye said.
Suspect appears in court
At his initial appearance yes-terday before Superior Court Judge Michael D. Farren, Mir-aglia was presented with copies of the murder complaints.
As Monmouth County Sheriff's Department officers led the shackled, lanky man with mussed chin-length hair into the jury box, he glanced at the gallery filled with reporters and court employees, then stared ahead and down.
Deputy Public Defender Theo-dore Fishman told Farren that Miraglia III would be repre-sented by his office. He said he hadn't yet interviewed Mirag-lia but told the judge he may file a motion to reduce the bail.
Farren kept Miraglia's bail at million but told Fishman he could file the motion at a later date.
Except for answering "I don't know yet" when asked by Far-ren where he would go if re-leased, Miraglia remained si-lent. The suspect is referred to in court documents as Rosario Miraglia III and refers to him-self that way, though his grand-father had a different middle name.