Ermintruder
The greatest risk is to risk nothing at all...
- Joined
- Jul 13, 2013
- Messages
- 6,209
Fascinating. Do you consider yourself to be the reactive product of faithless ancestors? And being entirely honest (which, of course, you must be) would you have become a Catholic if your family history had been that of devout believers?uair01 said:Nope. No such objects in my family. I'm the first Catholic (of the progressive sort) in two generations of Atheists.
Within your awoken belief, how do you feel God considers members of your family, those that are good, kind wonderful people, that do everything well in the world that the best of Christian Catholics would do? But they don't believe in him?
Do you consider a return to faith is something all children that have atheist parents should do? I'm sorry, I shall shut-up now, with my interested-but-puzzled questions.
I must look out for such a version, and see how it compares with the King James classic.uair01 said:But it was a special "literary" edition, without the chapter&verse numbers. Just text, printed like a novel. It is a very different reading experience from the traditional typography.
uair01 said:But not finding this Bible it is probably my punishment for swearing while searching for it. As I was groping in my bookcase, ten other books fell out and onto my foot. Then I used the Name Of The Lord in vain
In what way? If you believe in God, why wouldn't you instinctively use his name when experiencing shock and pain? Even people that think they don't believe in God will do this, always have in the past, fairly likely to do so in our respective remaining futures? If you have come to believe in God, don't you concede that on some levels maybe he's kind-of glad people swear and use his name when bad things happen? But not as much as when they swear a legal oath in court, or if they call on his name during a formal act of worship in a church (which will either be his own suprapersonal favourite, or the 'passeth understanding' clause may apply).
What if someone that believes in another God, deeply, personally and with all their soul, gets a fright or is hurt and consequently swears and takes the name of their God 'in vain'? As in "Oh Krishna, I've done ...."
Would the Christian God believed in by Catholics also be saddened by this action?
I'm just trying to understand how belief works, especially at the interface with other beliefs. Especially since all belief systems (aside from, allegedly, Buddism) know intrinsically that they are, by dint of their existence, more correct/perfected/attuned/valued than all the rest. Again by definition they know, for certain, both in the main and in the minor, that they are uniquely right, and the rest are assuredly wrong (21st Century religious tolerance aside).
Well done you on having bucked the trend. It shows character and a strand of special inner strength. But please be very very careful that I or others don't sway your regained faith. With pesky logic, or comparative religious paradoxes or deconstructionalist arguments. But ideally God wouldn't let that happen. After all, it would be unfair to both you and him. (shut up now, @Ermintrude !)